Profile of Mr Carmine

Avatar Area

Offline Unknown SteamID unknown
Posts: 1289

General Information


Thread: Why Stuart is sht compared to T7019 Mar 2022, 08:13 AM Jump back to quoted post18 Mar 2022, 18:45 PMVipper I am sorry but I couldn't follow. Is vet 3 luch easier to achieve than Stuart vet1? that was unclear yes. I meant to say the luch vets easier because of reliable damage output but reaching vet 3 as fast as the stuart reaches vet 1 isent the case. Its still a minor trivial detail in the whole issue USF have a little trouble scouting. They have the major with 50 vision and reckon planes, as stock something Axis faction do not get. It even "free" as some would say since it comes with teching. They also get Pathfinders (I&R Pathfinder) one of the best scouting unit at CP0 in one of the most common commander. indeed, okw and also ost just has more of it and more readely available, and even stronger options in doctrines* Yet top player use it all the time... how does this answer my question? How do the high cost for preformance and high mirco reqirements for low/situational impact make this unit balanced? That the best of the best use a unit that no else does doesnt mean a the unit is balanced. In: COH2 Balance
Thread: Why Stuart is sh*t compared to T7018 Mar 2022, 18:05 PM Jump back to quoted post17 Mar 2022, 21:46 PMVipper Kurobane asked a question and I replied with a similar question. Now you have asked and I had to reply. Stuart get first sight bonus at vet1 luch at vet 3. Do you really want to argue that is easier to get luch vet 3 than Stuart Vet 1? Here we go, adding trivial things to prove a point. Vision is not the main issue here. But ill humor you. The luch will vet easier but to vet isent as hard as vet 1. Okw (axis in general) has more vision or scouting and cloak options so the fact that the luchs gets it at vet 3 is a non issue. The stuart remains to weak for its cost and timing regardles of its vet 1 vision bonus. Its a 70 fuel pea shooter that can slow or snare vehicles. Other vehicles for that price and timing have far greater impact. Cost and mirco required is to high for its impact. Do you really think this is balanced? In: COH2 Balance
Thread: I think Ost pioneers should lose their sight bonus18 Mar 2022, 16:47 PM Jump back to quoted post18 Mar 2022, 16:23 PMWilly Pete Anyone still gunna talk pios? I think their sight is a bit much. Specially since they can open with mg42 Not that its gonna happen but the vision bonus range should be put behind a bp or upgrade for pios. In: COH2 Balance
Thread: Why Stuart is sh*t compared to T7017 Mar 2022, 21:34 PM Jump back to quoted post17 Mar 2022, 20:54 PMVipper Why does the luch need veterancy to less vision than a M3A3 at vet 0? How does that question relate to the topic? And unlike the stuart the luch excels in anti inf at least when compared directly. Its also a more usefull scout unit then the stuart. The stuarts damage output in general is just quite bad for its cost and timing. It needs to much input to get value out of it. In: COH2 Balance
Thread: Mg42 needs moar dps9 Mar 2022, 16:30 PM Haha yeah the best mg in the game isent the best in all things.. the shock. haha cant wait to see who takes this seriously. In: COH2 Balance
Thread: What really grinds your gears in CoH2?6 Mar 2022, 14:52 PM For me its: Smaller and larger game modes bot balanced seperate. Mostly Dlc factions used to miss or have very limited acces to basic tools such as snares mortars smoke mines. Not the case anymore but overnerfing/buffing units or abilities. Thank god this is not the case anymore. Deaming weak overpriced or up units currently fine because of past opness. Trying to make units seem up (mostly the panther) and others seem op af (mostly the t70) without stats or evidence. In: COH2 Gameplay
Thread: 120MM SOV mortar4 Mar 2022, 15:35 PM Jump back to quoted post4 Mar 2022, 12:37 PMBasedSecretary I cannot imagine what thoughts go through your head writing this, or how long it is since you opened the game. Soviets do not need FRP. They have the merge ability and dirt cheap reinforcement cons. You put more work setting up a FRP than actually reinforcing through merge. That's their basic mechanism. To not need FRP and be flexible due to merge. That way, you can reinforce very expensive units (like shocks or guards) for 18mp. Your argument is out of reality. That you directly compare merge to forward retreat point/healing and callin cons shitty inf is 100% out of touch. Seems you need to update your game. Cons havent been shitty for a while, when cons merge evevntualy they need to retreat regardless or they get wiped/used up, a fwrd retreat/reinforce point doesnt need to retreat. Your thinking isent very based atm. In: COH2 Balance
Thread: 120MM SOV mortar2 Mar 2022, 17:06 PM Jump back to quoted post2 Mar 2022, 13:23 PMleithianz Yeah it's more like a meta itself is too preferable for Soviet ATM. (I'm ofc talking about 1v1) Soviet is extremly mp cost efficient in defense scenario. First they have pile of 3(or 4) 7-man cons that only costs 18 mp to reinforce behind sandbag. The only problem with conscript is that they lack fire power, but that can be managed with guard rifle + 120mm + t34/85. I'm also +1 for removing retreat ability to pal with USF Pack Howi or OKW ISG. The retreat should stay. Soviets are quite lacking in forward healing and retreat points. Unlike the other factions. If we give soviets as much acces to those it can be removed as a trade off. In: COH2 Balance
Thread: buff 251 AA HT OKW2 Mar 2022, 15:11 PM Jump back to quoted post1 Mar 2022, 20:27 PMBasedSecretary Not at all. If you ever get out of level 2 you would know that even if you pop smoke there is a thing called "attack ground" which ruins your AA HT. Problem is not at all imaginary. The real problem is that the flak halftrack isent supurior in raw stats compared to other halftracks. A axis unit being weaker is not acceptable to axis players. The other real problem also is it has actual drawbacks such as requiering to be setup. It can be tricky to use. Most axis units are easier to use and dont require a lot of micro or utility to be effective. Axis players dont like such a unit. In: COH2 Balance
Thread: buff 251 AA HT OKW1 Mar 2022, 19:04 PM Jump back to quoted post1 Mar 2022, 16:51 PMBasedSecretary Agreed. It gets two shotted by snares and ATGs and cannot fire for shit. At least give it a little bit more armor to with stand two shots. Its called get out of jail free smoke. Thats your extra armour. At the push of a button. Imaginary problem solved. In: COH2 Balance