The reason I don't like to have debate with you is that you take all the words so "literally" without any sense of the context or common situation. I'm not sure what you think of it, but I think that leads to nowhere. And probably the reason many users in this forum is offensive to you.
When some says something like
It just means what it says in general gameplay. It's not a statement that requires "What?!? Vickers K can't win engagement vs. assualt gren?! I SHALL PROVE HIM WRONG!" and go for 5-man bolster up & 120 muni invested tommies behind green cover and make ass. gren to run from the front from the max range with nothing.
Exactly.
In mathematics and formal logic in general, there is a term that is used specifically to avoid trivial cases like this and it's "Without loss of generality", meaning that there is no need to take into account the most easy cases so as to not waste time.
That's just shows Vip's logic knowledge and application is underpar.