Login

russian armor

Are grenadiers worth their 30 MP reinforce cost?

8 Apr 2016, 08:29 AM
#21
avatar of Firesparks

Posts: 1930


And they even take the same pops as Obers!


wat, the ober squad cost 10 pop in total. 2 per man and 2 on the squad

the gren squad take 7 pop, 1 per man and 3 on the squad.
8 Apr 2016, 08:42 AM
#22
avatar of d0ggY
Senior Caster Badge

Posts: 823 | Subs: 3

Grenadiers can just really bleed you to death when you have to hold against an allied swarm of infantry while their medium tanks are already coming, of course become really potent, while also so fragile to literally every indirect fire. Since ostheer has already high teching cost with manpower, you kinda have to choose the right anmount of grenadiers, but i don't know if i would rebuild a grenadier if it's lost and rather go sniper, which vets incredible fast vs vet 3 squads of allies
8 Apr 2016, 08:42 AM
#23
avatar of Tiger Baron

Posts: 3145 | Subs: 2

Give em a 5th model, 25 per reinforcement man power and sandbags and there you go, not so shitty mainline infantry anymore.
8 Apr 2016, 08:47 AM
#24
avatar of Hikuran

Posts: 194



wat, the ober squad cost 10 pop in total. 2 per man and 2 on the squad

the gren squad take 7 pop, 1 per man and 3 on the squad.

Oops, sorry man my bad.
I will delete my inappropriate thread
8 Apr 2016, 08:49 AM
#25
avatar of Katitof

Posts: 17914 | Subs: 8

Give em a 5th model, 25 per reinforcement man power and sandbags and there you go, not so shitty mainline infantry anymore.

You forgot to rise the price to 280 at least or cut the damage by 25%.

Or buff con DPS by 30% to compensate?

edit: oh god, why are you even here? You're a full time comp stomper, balance is of no concern for you because you can just switch difficulty of AI...
8 Apr 2016, 09:10 AM
#26
avatar of RiCE

Posts: 284

I dont think Grens need a 5th man. I think the idea behind the higher reinforcement cost is in case of a smaller squad a single entity represents higher firepower. I mean if you have a single grens model, each member provides you 25% firepower, while in case of a 5 men squad its 20%.

So if i would change anything about Grens, its their received accuracy reduction. I think 4 men squads should generally have more received accuracy reduction. Except maybe IS, because they have an option to upgrade with a 5th man.
8 Apr 2016, 09:11 AM
#27
avatar of Aerohank

Posts: 2693 | Subs: 1

Grenadiers should be re-balanced to be a 5 man squad. Mainline infantry should be something you can rely on, not something that gets wiped by random explosions all the time.
8 Apr 2016, 09:18 AM
#28
avatar of Stug life

Posts: 4474

Make an upgrade on tier 3 to buff health of green and pg to 90-100
(And make ober have it from the start for some ra nerf)
8 Apr 2016, 09:23 AM
#29
avatar of SlaYoU

Posts: 400

Grenadiers should be re-balanced to be a 5 man squad. Mainline infantry should be something you can rely on, not something that gets wiped by random explosions all the time.


+1. They are far too weak (on the resilience side) to be reliable. Most of WM troubles come with their inability to hold areas of the map without having MG42 setup there. Then the 30mp / model bleed starts, and the slow death is on the way. I do think that Wehr players would gladly pay 280 / 30 for their grenadiers if they were 5 men squads, and the end result would help the faction in 1v1s. The whole idea of 4 men squads at first was that their were "elite infantry" when compared to Soviets' conscripts, who cost the same, but have 6 men to compensate their poor model to model comparison. With WFA and now Brits, Grenadiers are no longer elite, even if they stand their ground verse tommies (before double lmg and 5th man, obviously).
8 Apr 2016, 09:31 AM
#30
avatar of Katitof

Posts: 17914 | Subs: 8

jump backJump back to quoted post8 Apr 2016, 09:23 AMSlaYoU


+1. They are far too weak (on the resilience side) to be reliable. Most of WM troubles come with their inability to hold areas of the map without having MG42 setup there.

That is a problem why?
The faction is designed to rely on MG42 from get go. Grenspam strats are dead, because they were never intended to be a thing.

Then the 30mp / model bleed starts, and the slow death is on the way. I do think that Wehr players would gladly pay 280 / 30 for their grenadiers if they were 5 men squads, and the end result would help the faction in 1v1s.

Grens don't bleed more or less then any other mainline inf because of rec acc and their own firepower, unless you insist to fight in close range with rifles all the time.
Ost struggled vs early light vehicles, which was fixed by band aid 222 buff to boarderline op cost effectiveness in relation to any other light in game.

The whole idea of 4 men squads at first was that their were "elite infantry" when compared to Soviets' conscripts, who cost the same, but have 6 men to compensate their poor model to model comparison. With WFA and now Brits, Grenadiers are no longer elite, even if they stand their ground verse tommies (before double lmg and 5th man, obviously).


Wrong, the 4 men squads have nothing to do with them being elite or not, its to support army design of combined arms, you can NOT rely on grens alone, you need supporting units, either support weapons or command bunker/251 for map presence.

Grens never were supposed to be superior to any other infantry squad, so your elite argument desn't apply, they are supposed to be equal to cons and surpass them with weapon upgrades. Vs brits and UKF you have to use support units, just like UKF needs to do to support tommies.
8 Apr 2016, 09:48 AM
#31
avatar of robertmikael
Donator 11

Posts: 311

The grenadiers die too fast in the game and it is easy to squad wipe the squad.

Every infantry squad in the game could have more space between each soldier. It irritates me more when my Obersoldier-squad gets squad wiped by a single grenade, because they stay so close together.
8 Apr 2016, 09:49 AM
#32
avatar of SlaYoU

Posts: 400


That is a problem why?
The faction is designed to rely on MG42 from get go. Grenspam strats are dead, because they were never intended to be a thing.


Grens don't bleed more or less then any other mainline inf because of rec acc and their own firepower, unless you insist to fight in close range with rifles all the time.
Ost struggled vs early light vehicles, which was fixed by band aid 222 buff to boarderline op cost effectiveness in relation to any other light in game.



Wrong, the 4 men squads have nothing to do with them being elite or not, its to support army design of combined arms, you can NOT rely on grens alone, you need supporting units, either support weapons or command bunker/251 for map presence.

Grens never were supposed to be superior to any other infantry squad, so your elite argument desn't apply, they are supposed to be equal to cons and surpass them with weapon upgrades. Vs brits and UKF you have to use support units, just like UKF needs to do to support tommies.


And Wehrmacht has no trouble in 1v1s, right ? Cf the last post where i uploaded replays (and i know you remember it well, since you went poof as soon as i asked you some replays to back your points). And CF the ESL post that sums it quite nicely. Whatever.

Grens are not a reliable mainline infantry, that is a fact. And every time someones gets an idea to make the unit / faction viable again, you step in and spam your garbage.

USF is a nightmare early to mid game. Sovs and maxim are in a much better state than WM has ever been. Only UKF is a decent matchup for the faction. Otherwise you have to fight a downhill battle for 40 mins to actually have a chance to get back in the game after a (faction dependant) horrid start. If that's your view on Wehrmacht balance, then you have no say on it.
8 Apr 2016, 10:06 AM
#33
avatar of l4hti

Posts: 476

Grens are fine expect riflenade, id like to see side upgrade and timer to the nade
8 Apr 2016, 10:58 AM
#34
avatar of Katitof

Posts: 17914 | Subs: 8

jump backJump back to quoted post8 Apr 2016, 09:49 AMSlaYoU


And Wehrmacht has no trouble in 1v1s, right ? Cf the last post where i uploaded replays (and i know you remember it well, since you went poof as soon as i asked you some replays to back your points). And CF the ESL post that sums it quite nicely. Whatever.

Speaking of ESL, ost fare as good as OKW, they aren't any weaker then them.
You have that right there in the post you refer to.

Grens are not a reliable mainline infantry, that is a fact. And every time someones gets an idea to make the unit / faction viable again, you step in and spam your garbage.

If a car has flat tire and all the experts want to start from changing seats, upgrading engine and tanking jet fuel to fix that, then yeah, I'll step in.
It doesn't matter which side, if the suggestion is stupid, I'll gun it down as you can see in penal thread for example, where I'm opposed to most of mad ideas.
It just happens that there is more of these mad ideas from axis side then it is from allies as I'm not going to respond to any of aaa threads/posts.

USF is a nightmare early to mid game. Sovs and maxim are in a much better state than WM has ever been. Only UKF is a decent matchup for the faction. Otherwise you have to fight a downhill battle for 40 mins to actually have a chance to get back in the game after a (faction dependant) horrid start. If that's your view on Wehrmacht balance, then you have no say on it.

Ost has problems when the player tries to be aggressive.
You can't really be aggressive as ost, you're always responsive, just remind yourself how StephennJF played, how Hans plays. USF has no late game, so they need to be stronger in early and mid game.
Soviets, I'd hardly tell they are in better state then ost, they have their own problems, maxim is one of them, being the only valid infantry unit if you don't want to resort to early doctrinal commitment.
Ost had one huge weakness, lack of light armor counters, 222 buff removed that weakness and grens aren't supposed to fight on equal footing against rifles or tommies, you are supposed to back yourself with snipers or HMGs, if you don't, don't be surprised you struggle.
8 Apr 2016, 11:52 AM
#35
avatar of Iron Emperor

Posts: 1653

Grenadiers should be re-balanced to be a 5 man squad. Mainline infantry should be something you can rely on, not something that gets wiped by random explosions all the time.


+1, or let them atleast get the 5 man upgrade.
8 Apr 2016, 11:57 AM
#36
avatar of Ful4n0

Posts: 345

if greens become 5 man because of squad wipes, then, we should convert to 5 man squad JLI, and Assault engies from USF, and pathfinders and any squad with only four models...

Why greens but not obers??? why greens but no USF assault enginers????
8 Apr 2016, 12:08 PM
#37
avatar of Aerohank

Posts: 2693 | Subs: 1

jump backJump back to quoted post8 Apr 2016, 11:57 AMFul4n0
if greens become 5 man because of squad wipes, then, we should convert to 5 man squad JLI, and Assault engies from USF, and pathfinders and any squad with only four models...

Why greens but not obers??? why greens but no USF assault enginers????


Because Grens are the bread and butter of the Ostheer faction. They have to take the brunt of enemy fire. Every other faction has 4 man squads that are fairly easy to wipe, but these units are specialist units. Other factions will always have a hard-to-wipe core of units that acquires veterency to keep themselves standing and build an army around. Only Ostheer has its mainline infantry as permanent 4 man squads. This just gives the faction a weak foundation to build on.
8 Apr 2016, 12:13 PM
#38
avatar of SirWinshue HueHue

Posts: 118 | Subs: 1

Permanently Banned
- %20 recieved accuracy at vet1. Problem solved.



5 man grens does not work with ost.
8 Apr 2016, 12:14 PM
#39
avatar of Katitof

Posts: 17914 | Subs: 8

UKF have 5 man upgrade.

Hardly any streamer uses it, regardless of rank.

Can anyone explain to me why its not an issue for UKF?
8 Apr 2016, 12:15 PM
#40
avatar of Aerohank

Posts: 2693 | Subs: 1

UKF have 5 man upgrade.

Hardly any streamer uses it, regardless of rank.

Can anyone explain to me why its not an issue for UKF?


Pretty much every player uses that upgrade.

I can tell because I actually play the game.
0 user is browsing this thread:

Livestreams

unknown 24
unknown 21
unknown 7
Canada 2
Germany 1

Ladders Top 10

  • #
    Steam Alias
    W
    L
    %
    Streak
Data provided by Relic Relic Entertainment

Replay highlight

VS
  • U.S. Forces flag cblanco ★
  • The British Forces flag 보드카 중대
  • Oberkommando West flag VonManteuffel
  • Ostheer flag Heartless Jäger
uploaded by XXxxHeartlessxxXX

Board Info

946 users are online: 946 guests
2 posts in the last 24h
8 posts in the last week
39 posts in the last month
Registered members: 49080
Welcome our newest member, Keensler
Most online: 2043 users on 29 Oct 2023, 01:04 AM