Yes but what is the basis of your argument? What is the point you are trying to make? Are you trying to say that because shocks are offensive troops they shouldn't be in urban defense? Or do you just want to say, as I already said in the previous post you quoted "I think shocks are offensive troops and nothing have a nice day?" Because motive is important in discussions.
...
All these questions have already been answered in post 51.
Some people do not actually want be in a discussion, they are simply forum warriors who will argue for the sake of arguing and they tend to end up making silly claims which are inaccurate both historically and in game. This causes misinformation.
This only one example:
"shocks are just as much defensive as offensive"
It is my opinion that the forum should be a place, where one that reads the post becomes more informed instead of misinformed. This thread was create to clarify Shock troops role both in real life and in game.
Now if you want to discuss anything remotely related to Shock troops pls feel free to do, the rest are simply of topic and I have little intention of derailing this thread once more.