Let's Talk: ISG Performance

Jump back to quoted post19 Jul 2016, 06:56 AMullumulu

Hello,


if u nerf the range from ISG....how should the german fraction deal with sim city builders?

A nerf to the range means a big buff to the british forces.


I testet it...one morta emplacement can be faster repair than two ISG would do dmg.
it takes 7minutes (!) to kill one emplacment with 2 ISG only repaired by the british repair house.

while this 7min..the mortar emplacment do much dmg vs the ISG..i need 450 manpower to heal the ISG. That´s to much.

if u nerf the range....

Jump back to quoted post19 Jul 2016, 07:12 AMBrassatko

Not sure if Sim City should even be hard countered by just isg damage alone, once they also have the assembly and upgrades that is plenty of MP invested in it, no?

Jump back to quoted post19 Jul 2016, 07:12 AMBrassatko

But with the ability to smoke off the protecting elements one might be able to attack it with other units as well.

Jump back to quoted post19 Jul 2016, 07:29 AMJespe

So it would be Ok to autorepair Kingtiger by some sort of deployable halftrack so that 17pdr could not kill it until it fired it for about 7 minutes? Cause OKW Invested huge amount manpower and fuel for it?



Brits can just blast everything with attackground and bofors suppression when smoked...

Jump back to quoted post19 Jul 2016, 08:12 AMKatitof

Why aren't scatter values being mentioned?
These are THE primary stat of indirect fire weapon defining their effectiveness more then anything else.

Jump back to quoted post19 Jul 2016, 08:12 AMKatitof

As far as I've seen, ISG still uses heat seeking shells. You can't have indirect fire piece with good AoE and close to perfect accuracy.

Jump back to quoted post19 Jul 2016, 08:04 AMAustralian Magic

Just 2 days ago I watched Luvnet vs Zarok. Luv went for 2 ISGs to counter maxims, and Zarok for 2 120s to counter ISGs. Guess who won? ISGs or 120s? 120s had no chance.

Let's keep in mind that ISG is really, really accurate and it bases damage not on AoE but on accuracy.

Jump back to quoted post19 Jul 2016, 08:20 AMBrassatko

I'd like to see that replay. Maybe there is ab bit more to it than just ISGs hammering the poor 120s and maxims into the ground? So in fact the ISG is so strong it needs to be nerfed quite a bit in your opinion?

Jump back to quoted post19 Jul 2016, 08:17 AMDomine

And still it sucks.



Meanwhile the perfectly balanced, and as of latest fixed and behaving as intended USF mortar.

Jump back to quoted post19 Jul 2016, 07:49 AMBrassatko

1v1s I either manage to knock it out with ISG + raketen + infantry in the early stages, before the assembly point is in place or else I try to grab the rest of the map and get out tanks quicker than the opponent. They will not have map presence AND all that stuff early.

Jump back to quoted post19 Jul 2016, 08:28 AM__deleted__

I don´t know, if we buff it,

Jump back to quoted post19 Jul 2016, 08:32 AMsome one

u didn't read all

It would have autofire range 80 as mortar.

Jump back to quoted post19 Jul 2016, 08:32 AMsome one

u didn't read all

It would have autofire range 80 as mortar.

ISG have a slow rate of fire outside of barrage,