Login

russian armor

Buff for 5 man grens

PAGES (7)down
17 Apr 2021, 19:28 PM
#21
avatar of Jilet

Posts: 556


The problem is that Grenadiers focus their dps output around one model, 5 men lmg grenadiers would risk being op


What is the problem with having an upgrade that comes late but is mutually exclusive with the LMG then ?
17 Apr 2021, 19:30 PM
#22
avatar of jagd wölfe

Posts: 1660

jump backJump back to quoted post17 Apr 2021, 19:28 PMJilet


What is the problem with having an upgrade that comes late but is mutually exclusive with the LMG then ?

That nobody would ever use it. Why would you ever cripple yourself by losing so much firepower?
17 Apr 2021, 19:33 PM
#23
avatar of Jilet

Posts: 556


That nobody would ever use it. Why would you ever cripple yourself by losing so much firepower?


Why not give the option to do it ? "Nobody will use it" is a bad statement. I would personally stick with 1-2 of my Grens with LMGs and keep the last two or later replacements for wiped squads with the upgrade. There is no justification of keeping it as another 2CP upgrade. Just make it locked behind 3rd Tier and we have ourselves something unique and late game focused.
17 Apr 2021, 19:42 PM
#24
avatar of jagd wölfe

Posts: 1660

jump backJump back to quoted post17 Apr 2021, 19:33 PMJilet


Why not give the option to do it ? "Nobody will use it" is a bad statement. I would personally stick with 1-2 of my Grens with LMGs and keep the last two or later replacements for wiped squads with the upgrade. There is no justification of keeping it as another 2CP upgrade. Just make it locked behind 3rd Tier and we have ourselves something unique and late game focused.

Ok, let me get this
VSL adds another man, a weapon cooldown bonus and a volksgrenadier stg.
Nobody uses it because it's trash, and you want an upgrade that adds a 5th man... so that you can replace lmg grenadiers with grenadiers with an extra model... in late game
Is that right?
17 Apr 2021, 19:45 PM
#25
avatar of Jilet

Posts: 556


Ok, let me get this
VSL adds another man, a weapon cooldown bonus and a volksgrenadier stg.
Nobody uses it because it's trash, and you want an upgrade that adds a 5th man... so that you can replace lmg grenadiers with grenadiers with an extra model... in late game
Is that right?


I'm saying a revised model of this could be made to work and even 5 man grens would be just better than the current iteration of VSL just because they could at least alpha strike at times with their 16 damage rifles.
17 Apr 2021, 19:47 PM
#26
avatar of Katitof

Posts: 17914 | Subs: 8


That nobody would ever use it. Why would you ever cripple yourself by losing so much firepower?

Is that a rhetorical question or you seek an actual explanation from soviet players who use 7 man cons over SVT cons?
17 Apr 2021, 19:53 PM
#27
avatar of jagd wölfe

Posts: 1660

jump backJump back to quoted post17 Apr 2021, 19:47 PMKatitof

Is that a rhetorical question or you seek an actual explanation from soviet players who use 7 man cons over SVT cons?

There's no reason not to get SVT cons except being doctrinal
17 Apr 2021, 19:59 PM
#28
avatar of JPA32

Posts: 178

jump backJump back to quoted post17 Apr 2021, 19:33 PMJilet


Why not give the option to do it ? "Nobody will use it" is a bad statement. I would personally stick with 1-2 of my Grens with LMGs and keep the last two or later replacements for wiped squads with the upgrade. There is no justification of keeping it as another 2CP upgrade. Just make it locked behind 3rd Tier and we have ourselves something unique and late game focused.


Fundamentally a late game upgrade has to be incredibly powerful in some form because it's accessible for a shorter amount of time than standard upgrades thus providing less long term value. an example late game 5 man Grenadier upgrade would step on the toes of the existing LMG upgrade (Or any of the current existing upgrades for Grens depending on it's intention) which would cause it to either be overshadowed in it's role by a current upgrade, or completely transcend it and all others by being too powerful forcing you to wait for it with nearly no in-between which would be bad design.

That being said, current Gren design has it's own balancing issues with basically every usable doctrine at the moment being something that modifies or replaces Grens which is a symptom of a greater problem with the squad on a fundamental level.



17 Apr 2021, 20:33 PM
#29
avatar of Jilet

Posts: 556

jump backJump back to quoted post17 Apr 2021, 19:59 PMJPA32

Fundamentally a late game upgrade has to be incredibly powerful in some form because it's accessible for a shorter amount of time than standard upgrades thus providing less long term value. an example late game 5 man Grenadier upgrade would step on the toes of the existing LMG upgrade (Or any of the current existing upgrades for Grens depending on it's intention) which would cause it to either be overshadowed in it's role by a current upgrade, or completely transcend it and all others by being too powerful forcing you to wait for it with nearly no in-between which would be bad design.


We don't see such issues with SVTs or PPSh's tho do we ?

jump backJump back to quoted post17 Apr 2021, 19:59 PMJPA32

That being said, current Gren design has it's own balancing issues with basically every usable doctrine at the moment being something that modifies or replaces Grens which is a symptom of a greater problem with the squad on a fundamental level.


I agree on that one. Everyone uses Ostruppen with PGs nowadays.
17 Apr 2021, 20:35 PM
#30
avatar of JPA32

Posts: 178

jump backJump back to quoted post17 Apr 2021, 20:33 PMJilet


We don't see such issues with SVTs or PPSh's tho do we ?


We do, because PPSH are garbage and SVT are very good.
17 Apr 2021, 20:44 PM
#31
avatar of Protos Angelus

Posts: 1515

With the bullshit 7man upgrade existing I see no reason as to why Ostheer couldn't have the old 5men gren upgrade behind the T4 that can beat double bar RM. I mean 7men grens arrive so late that its ok that they beat g43gren cqc 100% of the time. With same idiotic logic of giving grens late game upgrade option instead of LMGs we could easily justify same broken bullshit of having good field presence and tools early but still super good scalability to late game. Same could be applied for OKW giving volks option to get LMG instead of STGs.

We could have nice things but unfortunately axis lost the war so they do not get the 7men treatment for late game.


LMG grens vet3 trade evenly at long range vs 2x BAR rifles. Also, PGrens exist to solve all your CQC needs. So you have PGrens which shit on rifles up to medium range and you have grens which trade evenly with rifles. All that in a vacuum. Put a werfer behind those units, and some other stuff, and you have a normal game. Cons are super shit early on, and gradually increase their strength through vet and 7th man. Absolute last infantry upgrade of all factions. If cons had P4s and PGrens next to them, then yeah, they would probably be OP as you would have a very strong combined arms force. But right now, comparing units between factions directly is idiotic at best
17 Apr 2021, 20:59 PM
#32
avatar of ZeroZeroNi

Posts: 1563


they would probably be OP as you would have a very strong combined arms force. But right now, comparing units between factions directly is idiotic at best

Every faction has stronbg combined arms options. No one is actually lacking anything.
18 Apr 2021, 02:26 AM
#33
avatar of thedarkarmadillo

Posts: 5279

jump backJump back to quoted post17 Apr 2021, 19:45 PMJilet


I'm saying a revised model of this could be made to work and even 5 man grens would be just better than the current iteration of VSL just because they could at least alpha strike at times with their 16 damage rifles.

16 damage for an alpha strike? That's the thing that got deliberately removed off of more expensive tommies isn't it? I'm 160% sure it is.

The value of the 5 man is taking your squishy 4 man squad and making is 25% more durable. That is the primary function. If you want firepower to ou take the lmh42 as it's primary function is to offset the squishy. Both upgrades have their uses and neither outright replaces the other this is an example of a good upgrade.
18 Apr 2021, 02:57 AM
#34
avatar of EtherealDragon

Posts: 1890 | Subs: 1



You mean where they get an extra model and improved firepower?


:lol:
18 Apr 2021, 07:17 AM
#35
avatar of Mr Carmine

Posts: 1289


16 damage for an alpha strike? That's the thing that got deliberately removed off of more expensive tommies isn't it? I'm 160% sure it is.

The value of the 5 man is taking your squishy 4 man squad and making is 25% more durable. That is the primary function. If you want firepower to ou take the lmh42 as it's primary function is to offset the squishy. Both upgrades have their uses and neither outright replaces the other this is an example of a good upgrade.


100% correct. The value for vsl is and should be durability and field presence not brute forcing at every range vs more expensive inf who dont have pgrens or obers and good mg's backing them up.

Now just tommies need a simaler aproach. Go bolster and takes 1 weapon slot or stay 4 men with two slots.

Updated the post.
18 Apr 2021, 08:00 AM
#36
avatar of LMAO

Posts: 163

vsl makes grens volks and we all know how good volks is and without sandbags
18 Apr 2021, 08:05 AM
#37
avatar of Katitof

Posts: 17914 | Subs: 8

jump backJump back to quoted post18 Apr 2021, 08:00 AMLMAO
vsl makes grens volks and we all know how good volks is and without sandbags

VSL have more DPS and more EHP then volks.
18 Apr 2021, 13:19 PM
#38
avatar of Jilet

Posts: 556


100% correct. The value for vsl is and should be durability and field presence not brute forcing at every range vs more expensive inf who dont have pgrens or obers and good mg's backing them up.

Every faction other than SOV have decent MGs. MG-42 being unparalleled is nothing but a myth nowadays.

Every other faction have their options to face the Panzergrenadier and the role of infantry being that split is unique to OST. (Which is good no complaints here)

Ober is not an OST unit you know.



Now just tommies need a simaler aproach. Go bolster and takes 1 weapon slot or stay 4 men with two slots.
Updated the post.


British infantry sections were problematic because they could go bolster super early (0.5-1 CP timing) and smash your infantry very early on with alpha strikes. I think you guys are really not understanding the difference between the impacts of a minute 1 alpha strike and an alpha strike at 25 minutes.
18 Apr 2021, 14:23 PM
#39
avatar of Mr Carmine

Posts: 1289

jump backJump back to quoted post18 Apr 2021, 13:19 PMJilet

Every faction other than SOV have decent MGs. MG-42 being unparalleled is nothing but a myth nowadays.

Every other faction have their options to face the Panzergrenadier and the role of infantry being that split is unique to OST. (Which is good no complaints here)

Ober is not an OST unit you know.




British infantry sections were problematic because they could go bolster super early (0.5-1 CP timing) and smash your infantry very early on with alpha strikes. I think you guys are really not understanding the difference between the impacts of a minute 1 alpha strike and an alpha strike at 25 minutes.


Compared to the maxim the mg42 is unparralleld. Soviet and usf need to tech towards it unlike ost okw and brits.

Pgrens are quite a powerfull ai squad, for the vsl to compete with them in dps terms with more hp will make vsl snowball and push pgrens out of use as we saw before. As vsl are cheaper and have more staying power and come quite early.

I was talking about axis in general, i know where obers belong. But they are besides the point actualy shoudnt have brought them up.

I understand perfectly how strong early upgrade alpha damage are. Hence i am in full agrement 7th man comes so late.
My suggestion with sections is to ty to them to hammer and anvil, the late game as it makes current sections snowball. I said that before but forgot to mention it this time.
18 Apr 2021, 18:50 PM
#40
avatar of Aarotron

Posts: 563

They need no buffs. They are good for now.
PAGES (7)down
1 user is browsing this thread: 1 guest

Ladders Top 10

  • #
    Steam Alias
    W
    L
    %
    Streak
Data provided by Relic Relic Entertainment

Replay highlight

VS
  • U.S. Forces flag cblanco ★
  • The British Forces flag 보드카 중대
  • Oberkommando West flag VonManteuffel
  • Ostheer flag Heartless Jäger
uploaded by XXxxHeartlessxxXX

Board Info

753 users are online: 753 guests
1 post in the last 24h
8 posts in the last week
36 posts in the last month
Registered members: 48939
Welcome our newest member, Ellmjnhiem
Most online: 2043 users on 29 Oct 2023, 01:04 AM