1. Casual versus Competitive: COH2 lacks a Day9 - a champion of the people, a man trying to elevate the basic players and make them better. That is my take on it. And, fundamentally, COH2 IS a casual game.
2. Snobbery: I find that snobbery goes far further than "lol compstomp" - The Gamereplays community was fundamentally toxic, angry, and bitter. I couldn't stand it there. At least on the official forums that atmosphere is different because they are all fans, they all love the game. GR was the height of snobbery. I don't see how new players could meet there. I feel like Snobbery is already on the way out with a new community like COH2.org being run by wise, experienced and decent folks, and supported by many others.
3. Content: I have no point on this, other than the fact is that Relic is excellent for making multiple, quality and enjoyable expansion packs. They incorperate feedback and make big changes, and it is ultimately for the best. Games like DOW2: Retribution show they listen.
4. Community: I sort of covered this in 2, but others have said it well enough - 3v3's and 4v4's make for terrible commentary. There's so much going on its difficult for a caster to focus on it. It isn't like football, where the camera follows the ball - its much more dynamic and busy than that. Its why 1v1 is the defacto standard of RTS - otherwise the level of complexity is too high. The way around this is to follow (again) Day9 - focus on that one guy in that 3v3 or 4v4, and see what he was doing for his team, what he could improve, etc.
5. Relic: IpKaiFung covered it best. If a game like SSBM can get that sort of following with nothing given up by Nintendo, we need to do a damn sight better towards Relic. This immediate "Rage @ Relic" thing needs to stop. They do a solid job. The community doesn't grow because of Relic - it grows because of people like Krebs and HelpingHans, and folks like AmiPolizeiFunk whom pour themselves into fansites and videos and try to get as many people involved as possible. Too much is laid at Relic's feet - we need to own up and make the community grow, and folks like Noun will be there when shit hits the fan to pick up the pieces
6. Glad to comment on your stuff. Their great talking points
