While I appreciate some of the opinions of the posters in this thread. You have to admit this is no more pay to win than the expansions to CoH 1 were.COH1's expansions where a Hybrid Standalone style (ala DOW: Dark Crusade which released the same year as COH). TOV included everything for free from the originals, and was a "complete edition" akin to Retribution for DOW2.
The Hybrid standalone can indeed fall under the broad p2w definition people are using in this thread. The fact was that original COH players got something out of it - more variety, more opponents to face, different gameplay, etc. People don't like being split up, and Relic prevented them from doing so. There were huge content patches that put all the new maps in for free for existing players. It was a good deal for them.
This is much the same. I don't see why people are complaining. Or do they truely believe these four new commanders are that amazing? 80 fuel for a build that can be smashed by artillery strikes? hah.