Axis
Panzer IV 170-234
Panther 270
Tiger 300
Brummbar 260-300
Sturmtiger 220
Tiger II 375
Elefant 400
Jagdtiger 450
Allies
Sherman variants up to 215
Comet 290
Churchill Croc/AVRE 290
Churchill Mk.VII 240
Pershing 270
IS-2 340
KV-1 270
KV-2 300
KV-8 260
ISU 340
Except for the superheavy TDs, Axis hardly have more or better armored tanks.
that show in each class of target, i.e medidum to medium tank; heavy to heavy tank; heavytd to heavy td, axis more often have more armor. Like p4 have more armor than all sherman variant, bumbar(vet) have more armor than all churchill variant, etc.
in total, axis have 5 vehicle with 300+ armor, alies have 3, axis have 3 vehicle with 350+ armor, alies have none, what about that ?
And the point is that axis have more armor in general that 20 more pen that the pershing have over the tiger is not an advantage.