Profile of Kirrik

Avatar Area

Offline Unknown SteamID unknown
Posts: 573

General Information


Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch12 Sep 2018, 13:55 PM ER meant to fix to crit damages not give you free repairs There is good reason only Allies had proper repair abilities while Germans didnt. I'm sure you figure out why auto-repairing Panthers and KT would be a huge problem In: Lobby
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch12 Sep 2018, 13:36 PM Jump back to quoted post12 Sep 2018, 11:55 AMStark This includes teamgames. If you afraid of stuka/offmap wipping - don't use it but don't block the option for others. I would be good if they added some sort of healing to the commander (replacing 1 model for a healer sound interesting) 1 model is utterly pointless, it will be enough to heal one squad at best, even 4 medics at sov HQ have serious problems keeping up with injured infantry in late game. Besides if Commisar gets a retreat point it's only a matter of time before people start asking for same thing for OST. If retreat point stays they simply need to give this doctrine a way to heal troops, otherwise its going to turn nasty in team games, I dont want Sov horde squatting near my forward assembly when playing Brits In: Lobby
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch12 Sep 2018, 11:39 AM The point is - it was a great ability and it was removed from Osttruppen just for sake of something new. It was unneeded change and it made commander weaker in late game. Same would happen if Relay is removed from Armored Elite In: Lobby
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch12 Sep 2018, 11:23 AM Nothing was changed or replaced about resource conversion, its still on CAS and Luftwaffe. Osttrupen commander got it's ability removed for a sake of changes. Relay is not situaltional in any way, its cheap and always useful in late game against any faction. In: Lobby
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch12 Sep 2018, 10:48 AM Armored Elite does not need anything else, it never needed rework in first place, it just needed buffs to lackluster stuff it got. Changes just for the sake of changes are bad, thats how Osttruppen ended up with useless supply drop - people thought resource conversion wasnt good enough and "commander needed something else". Relay is recon ability of this commander, sticking into another commander, especially Overwatch is pointless - that one already has good recon on its own In: Lobby
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch12 Sep 2018, 00:34 AM Regarding Commisar, if blobbing was a concern why give that squad retreat point? Soviets dont actually have non-doc healing outside of their base meaining the only way you can realistically use it is parking your commisar near UKF forward assembly or USF Ambulance and we all know it will end very badly with stuka/offmap wiping everything out Grenade was a step in right direction, retreat point in my opinion is not. Unless you want to give this commander a ZiS-6 truck which reinforce and can drop healthpacks or something like that, retreat point will become pointless due to fact you'll have to send your troops back to base for healing, in fact it will become a drawback due to reinforcement penalties In: Lobby
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch11 Sep 2018, 22:49 PM KV-2 changes are great, I expected a siege mode buff, but making it into a proper heavy tank which can actually fight instead of derping around the battlefield is great too, especially for Urban/Industry since they lack KV-1/T-34-85 to help them out in late game I hope IS-2 will also recieve Inspire instead of cap territory, its pointless for heavy tanks. Regarding Signal Relay - It ABSOLUTELY should not get replaced, knowing where enemy tanks are concentrated before sending in Sturmtiger or raiding party of p4 is crucial, currently its most useful ability on commander aside of heat shells P.S About this Stormtrooper whining, have you considered just spawning them with 2 rifles and 2 mp40 and then simply giving them option to upgrade to either 2xMP40 or 4xStg? This way everyone will be happy. Maybe that additionnal 2xMP40 upgrade might slightly buff their RA, kinda like MP40 does for Volks in Firestorm doc. In: Lobby
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch11 Sep 2018, 20:34 PM No, Stug E is not okay at all, it requires four shots for from AT gun to kill with 560HP Any AT gun aside maybe ZiS will simply get wiped while trying ot kill it, thats way too strong for it's cost and CP it comes at In: Lobby
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch11 Sep 2018, 20:15 PM How is bulldozer being able to do it's job is a problem? The whole point of dozer changes is to make it more like brummbar, Stug E clearing AT guns is clearly not okay combined with HP buff, but dozer performs like it's supposed to That thing has not AT, if it cant clear infantry then it's pointless in first place In: Lobby
Thread: Commander Revamp Patch - Bug List11 Sep 2018, 19:56 PM Not strictly speaking a bug but an oversight: Assault Guards (Lend Lease) dont get buff Shock PPSh got since their PPSh despite having exact same damage profile are separate/got unique name with copy-pasted Shock PPSh stats They should either get same buff for their PPSh or get actual shock PPSh's instead of copy-pasted clone with different name In: Lobby