Coh1 is "balanced" in that the vanilla factions can fight each other competitively. The meta game has been solved at this point, so it's all about who outplays the other player. Everybody knows the buildorders and what will counter it, now it's all about the execution.
Alot of the love for coh1 comes from nostalgia, but that doesn't mean there aren't a lot of stuff done better. Faction design, the commander system, the resource system, map layout, veterancy system were all better. People still talk about them because they are still good. People hoped CoH2 would improve and reach for these ideals. It wont happen now.
I don't think coh1 is a better game now though. Coh2 has matured and come a long way since release. CoH2 was a piece of trash on release, that soured the opinion of many vcoh veterans. Since all the improvements to things like squad spacing and unit control in egagements the game has become a lot more fluid. Coh2 has also finally got rid of most of the fucking annoying and frustrating units. vCoH snipers give me AIDS.
CoH2 factions can't fight each other competitively? i mean there is a faction showdown clock on my screen right now
Faction design seem the same to me.
Commander system COH1 limited you to 3 but i do love blitzkrieg doctrine but they had mechanized assault and those are pretty much alike
Resource system well i love that in COH2 general point give you fuel and munitions and fuel income it way lesser then in COH1 it feel like if not then again no big different
Map layout ehhhhhhhh can't tell at all
Veterancy system you had to agree with me that COh2 do a better job at this.German can upgrade vertancy with 1 building while rifleman take allday to vet up to 2,ranger don't even vet at all.Brit "more lieutenant lad the more the better for our ventancy" lol,Panzer elite vet up so easily.
Oh and btw arty in COH1 you can't dodge it most of the time Hans shown me this.
I love estern mod but now mostly just watch it from my COH2 caster sometimes.But why no 88gun in coh2 why do we get the pak 43 WHYYYYY
COH2 is shit at release well i didn't know that,those IGN guy must had played the game a while after release to score the game that high 8,4/10