Comet Vet 1 "White Phosphorus"

Jump back to quoted post21 Oct 2015, 13:08 PMPuppetmaster

I just used it on a King Tiger, seemed to block vision. That said it is super unreliable, I've never had it fire while moving and I would say it only works 20 - 50% of the time when stopped.

I would suggest adjusting the muni cost to probably 30, fix it so it actually works 100% of the time and is fire-able while on the move. That way it can actually be used effectively offensively and defensively instead of a sure way to stop your tank for little effect.

After that the range can probably be adjusted but until the ability fixed, it kinda requires the range so you can safely use it (if it bothers to work at all)

Jump back to quoted post21 Oct 2015, 13:10 PMBananenheld

"So you can use it safely" is a Bad balance agrument

Jump back to quoted post21 Oct 2015, 13:13 PMPuppetmaster

Well right now the only way it might work is to stop your tank. Doing that near any kind of at / snare is death to the tank. You can only use it far away if you want your tank to live.

I doubt you have even used the ability at all to know how broken it is trying to get it to work.

Jump back to quoted post21 Oct 2015, 13:20 PMBananenheld

It's broken that you cant use it on the move, it will get fixed (99%) and on top of that u want the range to be the same?
Edit: my playercard should be visible, you dont need to make assumptions, I dont even have britz Expansion

After that the range can probably be adjusted but until the ability fixed, it kinda requires the range so you can safely use it (if it bothers to work at all)

Jump back to quoted post21 Oct 2015, 13:32 PMPuppetmaster

GJ with the reading fail



The fact that you have never used it doesn't really put you in a position to comment on its balance because as I said, you have no 1st hand experience of how broken it is trying to get it to fire.

Also since you are claiming its 99% going to be fixed so it can be fired on the move, can you link your source?

Jump back to quoted post21 Oct 2015, 13:50 PMBananenheld

Hey stuka's flame barrage is buggy atm, Let's buff stuka till they fixed it.

Jump back to quoted post21 Oct 2015, 14:18 PMPuppetmaster

Please quote where I suggested to buff it in its current state.

Jump back to quoted post21 Oct 2015, 09:41 AMBananenheld

It's britz it is intended. Just look at the sniper who could kill retreating squads 100%, their wp can crit and thus wipe a squad, centaurs insta gibbing everything, their at gun a pak with a 50% modifier and many more. Check out Cruzz Bugs List, there are so many small things which got taken away from every other faction. Its really obv that brits got Released uber op and it needs another 1-2 Patches of nerfs to bring them inline.

Jump back to quoted post21 Oct 2015, 14:48 PMdaspoulos

lol fuckin lelic giving blatantly OP abilities just cuz $$$

Jump back to quoted post21 Oct 2015, 20:07 PMdaspoulos

Wouldnt be too much of an issue if it fired from 50 range, not 70 hahaha. Also the white phosphorus kills arbitrarily? No other white phosphorus does that for a reason. But brits are exempt just cuz? Its like a tank shooting volk incendiary grenade from long range that damages faster, slows and kills the target. For what was it 15 muni? More like a unit deletion shell rather than smoke.

Jump back to quoted post23 Oct 2015, 13:22 PMWingZero

I really don't see the abuse here with the Phosphorus rounds.Very rarely, I see people even teching for Comet, majority of the time I see Churchills.

Jump back to quoted post23 Oct 2015, 13:22 PMWingZero

I really don't see the abuse here with the Phosphorus rounds.Very rarely, I see people even teching for Comet, majority of the time I see Churchills.

Jump back to quoted post23 Oct 2015, 13:29 PMKatitof

Just wait for patch, then churchill becomes glorified KV-1 and it'll be all about comets and nothing more.