Says the guy with ZERO soviet games played XD
Played both during the beta, decided I like the German side more and committed to only play one side in competitive automatch, I took the same strategy in COH1 and it kept me in the top 50 for the first 6 months of the game. I frequently play as soviets in custom matches to try out strats I have problems with to see which German counters work.
That aside, those remain the problems as I see it from a player with a German perspective.
1. Soviets have better mines, they have far more utility. Few would disagree
2. The Stug is useless, particularly when you match it against the SU-85 which is a far greater Tank destroyer for a very modest increase in price. Few would disagree with this analysis.
3. RNG. Tin Cans immobilizing Tiger Tanks with a roll of the dice. Few players would disagree with the RNG issues COH2 has.
4. Squad wipes being worse on the German side are a fact.
5. Tell me a German strategy and I'll tell you a soviet doctrine that will counter it, you simply can't say that from the other perspective because, with the exception of the Assault doctrine, German doctrines don't provide decisive counters to soviet tactics until well into the game e.g. the Elefant, Tiger.