Profile of Kirrik

Avatar Area

Offline Unknown SteamID unknown
Posts: 573

General Information


Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch13 Nov 2018, 01:57 AM Ugh, why nerf all booby traps though? If anything they all should've had OKW booby damage profile to justify cost and limits compared to plain normal mines. Heavy damage to one squad does not do much compared to actually killing models mines do. Would it not be better to just turn booby traps into better AI mines with 3 models kill limit? I mean these things cost more than mines and are doctrinal/on elite units. Arent they supposed to be better than plain mines? In: Lobby
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch5 Nov 2018, 12:37 PM Jump back to quoted post5 Nov 2018, 10:16 AMSander93 As for one major change I would really like to stress the consideration of replacing Overwatch's LeFH 18 with the Jagdtiger. The LeFH 18 feels out of place. It fits the doctrine much better and there was a lot of positive reaction to the idea. Unless you guys already discussed and dismissed this? IMO there's also still the issue of the 221 coming out a bit too late for what it can do (practically saw no use in the tournament). IMO it should be buildable after having an SWS truck out with a bit longer build time. If object collision can't be fixed, it should be worked around by: 1) Slightly higher arc with increased speed (same time to hit); 2) Decrease random scatter so the player can actually manually aim around obstacles. Jaeger Light Infantry need some lower requirements. They have very good vet but the current requirements are through the roof. It should be 1/4 to 1/3 lower I think. You realize they get insane RA bonuses with veterancy compared to Pathfinders? They dont need any more buffs considering they are already flat out better than their US counterpart Also I really hope finalizing changes means giving booby traps to actual combat units instead of engineers and making AT overwatch actually track faster instead of ramping up and missing all the shots on moving targets anyway. In: Lobby
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch30 Oct 2018, 10:59 AM KV-8 IS a late game unit, what kind of "shock value" you're talking about when OKW could have Panther by the time KV-8 even hits field? If KV-8 to remain in current state it had to be limited to just 1 same as AVRE and Sturmtiger, it's gun performance is equal to KV-1 gun against armor, its basically KV-1 with flamethrower which would be hilariously OP in 2+ numbers In: Lobby
Thread: New Commander concepts.29 Oct 2018, 19:13 PM A Paratrooper commander for Soviets makes sense since it wont need any new assets considering it could be something like combination of Ost CAS/Luftwaffe doctrines and USF Airborne Munition abilities would be Il-2 recon, IL-2 loiter and Il-2 bomb strike Doctrinal units would paratroopers (which could use male sniper models) with SVT's and DP-28 upgrade making them AI-only variant of Guards and DShK drop Alternatively DShK could be bundled with Paratroopers and still unused ZiS truck can be brought as an soviet ambulance to heal and reinforce at frontlines. In: COH2 Gameplay
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch28 Oct 2018, 16:50 PM Am I only one finding it hilarious people started crying about KV-8 when it got turned into a soviet Brummbar - unit which not only hardcounters AT infantry and AT guns but also can fight off enemy mediums? Not that it's a good thing considering Brum is clearly OP Giving KV-8 T-70 gun with a slower reload and ability to use it alongside flamethrower would be far more balanced in the end - at least unit would have clear definitions what it counters and what its countered by, intead of a unit which can take on armor or infantry with a single click switch weapons Also if you look at stats of 45mm gun and its reload speed its obvious that its almost same pen and DPS of KV-1 except KV-8 also can switch to a flamethrower. Like I said before - these last round changes were either rushed due to no time for proper testing or clearly not very well thought out In: Lobby
Thread: Artillery Flares of OKW's Special Operations Commander28 Oct 2018, 16:33 PM The easiest fix is to make ability function like UKF artillery commander ability Or just give flares to leigs or volks In: COH2 Balance
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch27 Oct 2018, 11:12 AM Jump back to quoted post27 Oct 2018, 10:45 AMSander93 Maybe try to give some constructive feedback for once instead of just pointlessly whining about everything. Do you think anyone of the team is going to take your complaints serious if you present them like this? So the tracking of the ability doesn't work well yet. Moving targets do not get hit, so the ability should be tweaked to deal more damage to moving vehicles before they leave the area. Damage against stationary targets is fine though, could kill a King Tiger two times over. Anti-tank ability to a commander with zero anti-tank themed abilities because commander has too much anti-infantry tools? Booby traps to egineers when axis unit who have them are either frontline troops or infiltration units? Another funny thing: you STILL cant dodge panzer commander artillery with a snared heavy (and that gets ignored) meanwhile NKVD gets clearly untested and untuned AT Overwatch which cant hit one of the slowest tanks in game which is reversing while snared? Considering all of this clearly not much thought is given to those changes in first place, calling out mod team of unneeded changes and bizzare nerfs is reasonable feedback In: Lobby
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch27 Oct 2018, 09:51 AM Well I've just seen NKVD Anti-tank overwatch in action. A snared KT reversing is completely undamaged, for a 200 munitions. I guess I have to take my words on booby trap back, NKVD got even bigger waste of munitions this patch AND lost one of the best infantry area denials in game in process In: Lobby
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch26 Oct 2018, 03:02 AM Just a reminder - Urban defense after this patch has zero munitions sinks as a commander, on a faction that already floats munitions due to no weapons upgrades. If offmap booby trap was that overpowered instead of nerfing them to a useless state you could've either increased their cost or just gone ahead and swapped ability back for Incendiary Barrage , it certanly not the best offmap in game but at very least it will give commander a munition sink that is neither useless nor "op" In: Lobby
Thread: Feedback for Commander Revamppatch25 Oct 2018, 21:33 PM What about booby trap, with its current stats you might as well replace it with armored vehicle detection, it might be at very least useful in combination with M-42. A 45 munition for a trap that is weaker than mine on a unit that can plant mines is like M-42 stuck in Tier 2 with ZiS and costing 450mp In: Lobby