At least 3 of 5 abilities in USSR commander should be changed because of:
1. Some patches ago Relic remove all resourse manipulations. (That's why manpower blitz should be changed)
2. It is breaking one of the main mechanic in the game, and it is sooooo stereotyped (i am talking about forbidden retreat for soviet infantry). This game already have enough stereotypes about Red Army.
3. USSR already have one doctrine ability, which immobolizing infantry - Hit the dirt. And this ability useless. Germans vechicle will just crush all you infantry without any problems (Here i am talking about Hold the Line! ability)
Edit: i have looked at German commander, he need some changes too:
1. Change Munition Blitz.
2. No need in incerdinary ammo for mortar, Wehrmacht already have them with SdKfz 250 Mortar Halftruck.
3. Assault Panzergrenadiers can be changed on Assault package for Panzergrenadiers which give all abilities from Assault Panzergrenadiers, but with 1 Flamethrower.
Sorry if you are offended by these stereotypes, but Relic was the one who created these abilities, not me. For the resource manipulation, I decided to not remove it to try to give everyone a better look at what these commanders really are like. I did change a few things on them to keep it from being completely game breaking (like I said indirectly on the main post), but I didn't want to remove any abilities, because it wouldn't correctly display the commanders (and I really don't want to take more time to replace them.) Hit the dirt, in my opinion, is still a very good ability for infantry vs infantry combat, and even though tanks can simply run them all over, AT guns, and other AT weaponry still work, so it isn't as bad as you may think in most situations. The incendiary ammo for the Sdkfz 250 Mortar Half-track isn't a good reason to remove this, because the 250 Half-track is doctrinal to other commanders, not to the base faction. Finally, for your proposed change to the Urban Assault Panzergrenadiers, I think it's the same thing as saying Assault Grenadiers should become an upgrade on normal Grenadiers.
Have a good day!
~Hans G. Schultz