Login

russian armor
COH2.ORG » Forums » Parlor Room » COH2 Central » COH2 Balance » Comet tank has been too nerfed.

Comet tank has been too nerfed.

PAGES (6)down
New topic New topic     Upload replay New Reply
Katitof
3 May 2019, 19:15 PM
#101
avatar of Katitof

Posts: 17914 | Subs: 8

jump backJump back to quoted post3 May 2019, 19:09 PMStug life
I already posted my opinion above, it’s just false saying the Cromwell or the comet are bad in ai, again it’s just a scaled down tiger

For the cost? Comet is pretty damn bad at AI, being a generalist.
Imagine panther penetration tops at 200, that's the level of underperforming that comet is at.
Inb4 sneks barge in, screaming "grenades", yeah, at vet3 and range 15 - you know what's also at that range? Faust.

Accuracy does nothing vs infantry and lack of reload pretty much crosses out scaling.
Comets vet is so damn bad its not even funny.
jump backJump back to quoted post25 Nov 2015, 11:09 AM$nuffy
Maybe it's 'cause the Axis players aren't a bunch of forum crybabies, and they keep their cool and fight the uphill battle, unlike some of their "allied" counterparts.
Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
thedarkarmadillo
3 May 2019, 19:52 PM
#102
avatar of thedarkarmadillo

Posts: 5279

jump backJump back to quoted post3 May 2019, 18:52 PMJibberJabberJobber


Yes, thank you, it can crush infantry better, incredibly useful.

I've paid 200 manpower + 50 fuel to unlock Hammer, then 500 manpower + 185 fuel for a tank that has less AI than a P4 (same aoe/scatter, similar hull mg's, but no pintle mg and +0,7s rof) that still gets clubbered by a Panther (-160 HP, -50 pen, +0,8s rof, -5 range, for slightly more armor and speed).

Now we can either buff the AT of the Comet and create unstoppable Comet/Firefly combo's or we can buff it's AI as befits an expensive general purpose tank with worse AT than a Panther. Most would agree something has to be done.

I don't mean to alarm you but the panther is supposed to beat the comet. Just so you know when you are making your comparison. Actually the comet was nerfed SPECIFICALLY because it was beating the panther (which it's not supposed to do)
Also your hammer teching also provides buffs to other units it's not a straight single purpose teching choice like conscript upgrades or brit nades/bofors/AEC that only unlock a single thing. Hammer also grants tracking that makes all your armour better, blitz which makes all your armour better and gammons which are in dire need of a buff (into multipurpose satchels would be ideal I think) or possibly even changed outright into smoke grenades or something.
All that comes with hammer needs to be accounted for in the tech.
#stalinwept
Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
T.R. Stormjäger
3 May 2019, 19:56 PM
#103
avatar of T.R. Stormjäger

Posts: 3588 | Subs: 3

jump backJump back to quoted post2 May 2019, 21:08 PMmiragefla


No, as the Comet is supposed to be the opposite of the Churchill and act as a mobile tank versus the slow meatshield.

Things to address:

Veterancy: The unit needs some form of offensive veterancy to help it engage targets later on. Few, if any other vehicles have 0 bonuses to either reload, or penetration. While the Comet does get accuracy, its firepower for the most part is the same from stock to veterancy 3.

One might count on the auto-grenades as a substitute, but then you're getting in close and it doesn't help vs most vehicles that the Comet will engage.

Moving Accuracy: With the current state, I don't think returning its 0.75 moving accuracy would be terrible to emphasize its status as a mobile tank as that's its whole point.


What if it fired “special rounds” that did more damage to rear armour? You’d promote mobile gameplay and flanking, without the buffs that would make it op.

There’s already something similar with the KV1 received damage modifier.
Playercard of T.R. Stormjäger

1v1: Pstreak: - 1
1v1: Pstreak: + 1
1v1: 14streak: - 2
1v1: Pstreak: - 7


Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
JibberJabberJobber
3 May 2019, 19:57 PM
#104
avatar of JibberJabberJobber

Posts: 1614 | Subs: 3

jump backJump back to quoted post3 May 2019, 19:52 PMthedarkarmadillo

I don't mean to alarm you but the panther is supposed to beat the comet. Just so you know when you are making your comparison. Actually the comet was nerfed SPECIFICALLY because it was beating the panther (which it's not supposed to do)
Also your hammer teching also provides buffs to other units it's not a straight single purpose teching choice like conscript upgrades or brit nades/bofors/AEC that only unlock a single thing. Hammer also grants tracking that makes all your armour better, blitz which makes all your armour better and gammons which are in dire need of a buff (into multipurpose satchels would be ideal I think) or possibly even changed outright into smoke grenades or something.
All that comes with hammer needs to be accounted for in the tech.


You didn't get my point. It has worse AT than a Panther, but no AI to make up for it. I clearly requested buffing it's AI instead of AT in both my posts (read Comet/Firefly bit in my last alinea).

If OP's video is to be believed, even a pintled Panther outperforms it in AI, altough I know Pintle vs cannon comparisons are pretty RNG based.

Hammer providing other bonusses: fair enough, but without it I can't get to my overpriced Comet.
Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
Lago
3 May 2019, 20:08 PM
#105
avatar of Lago

Posts: 3260

jump backJump back to quoted post3 May 2019, 19:57 PMJibberJabberJobber
You didn't get my point. It has worse AT than a Panther, but no AI to make up for it. I clearly requested buffing it's AI instead of AT in both my posts (read Comet/Firefly bit in my last alinea).

If OP's video is to be believed, even a pintled Panther outperforms it in AI, altough I know Pintle vs cannon comparisons are pretty RNG based.

Hammer providing other bonusses: fair enough, but without it I can't get to my overpriced Comet.


If memory serves, on stats alone, it's got the anti-infantry performance of a Cromwell. Same MGs, same AoE profile on the main gun.
Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
JibberJabberJobber
3 May 2019, 20:17 PM
#106
avatar of JibberJabberJobber

Posts: 1614 | Subs: 3

jump backJump back to quoted post3 May 2019, 20:08 PMLago


If memory serves, on stats alone, it's got the anti-infantry performance of a Cromwell. Same MGs, same AoE profile on the main gun.


That is correct. Slower reload tho.
Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
thedarkarmadillo
4 May 2019, 02:12 AM
#107
avatar of thedarkarmadillo

Posts: 5279

jump backJump back to quoted post3 May 2019, 19:57 PMJibberJabberJobber


You didn't get my point. It has worse AT than a Panther, but no AI to make up for it. I clearly requested buffing it's AI instead of AT in both my posts (read Comet/Firefly bit in my last alinea).

If OP's video is to be believed, even a pintled Panther outperforms it in AI, altough I know Pintle vs cannon comparisons are pretty RNG based.

Hammer providing other bonusses: fair enough, but without it I can't get to my overpriced Comet.

Its got better smoke abilities than the panther though. Better grenades thrown through the hatches type abilities too. Also while tracking effects all vehicles its quite literally impossible to have a comet without it, so it's ability to track enemy armour into the fog of war is also superior.

While I do think the comet needs some small things you can't simply compare something hard like stats without accounting for soft things that improve the units battlefield presence like abilities. Tracking on its own isn't too flashy, but when combined with something like an AT gun or FF it can mean getting an extra hit in.
And the smoke is self explanatory. WP more so.
The nades are a wee bit trickier but still there I guess...
#stalinwept
Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
IncendiaryRounds:)
4 May 2019, 21:53 PM
#108
avatar of IncendiaryRounds:)

Posts: 1527

Permanently Banned
Better AOE and some sort of reload bonus at vet 2. Call it a day. Brits don't need more AT, I'm sure most would rather have AI right now.
"I wish THQ was still alive and made CoH2. Ostheer for life."

PLAYERCARD: https://www.coh2.org/ladders/playercard/steamid/76561198287328305
Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
Rocket
4 May 2019, 21:56 PM
#109
avatar of Rocket

Posts: 728

jump backJump back to quoted post4 May 2019, 21:53 PMIncendiaryRounds:)
Better AOE and some sort of reload bonus at vet 2. Call it a day. Brits don't need more AT, I'm sure most would rather have AI right now.


Yep pretty much
Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
LoopDloop
5 May 2019, 00:48 AM
#110
avatar of LoopDloop

Posts: 3053

jump backJump back to quoted post4 May 2019, 21:53 PMIncendiaryRounds:)
Better AOE and some sort of reload bonus at vet 2. Call it a day. Brits don't need more AT, I'm sure most would rather have AI right now.

+1

I'd consider buffing scatter rather than AoE though. Make it hit models more consistently without wiping entire squads or anything like that. IMO comet shells are fine when they do hit, it's just they don't hit that often. I guess buffing AoE would make them hit more too but that might be a little stronger, which would too much IMO. That's all conjecture though.
Playercard of LoopDloop

1v1: P2v2: P3v3: P4v4: P
1v1: P2v2: P3v3: P4v4: P
1v1: P2v2: P3v3: P4v4: P
1v1: P2v2: P3v3: P4v4: P


Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
Balanced_Gamer
9 May 2019, 09:46 AM
#111
avatar of Balanced_Gamer

Posts: 783

Nerf Price for Comet. Take away Phosphorous shot since it has smoke. Phosphorous shot is a bit too much. Maybe replace Phosphorous with Throwing a Flare, arty flare. Maybe give it the possibility to have an another upgrade, an MG upgrade.

Currently it costs 500 manpower and 185 fuel. I think it should be around 450 manpower and 170-175 fuel, around there, nerf price for its current state. Maybe Armour needs some nerfing. A bit too much than it was irl.
I enjoy Coh2. I want this game to be balanced as it can possibly be forukfukfusfusfokwokwsovietssovietsostheerostheer. Do not judge me, for my opinion is balanced. B-)

This is my playercard number if you are curious: https://www.coh2.org/ladders/playercard/steamid/76561198127033144

Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
Loliholic
9 May 2019, 12:11 PM
#112
avatar of Loliholic

Posts: 36

Permanently Banned
jump backJump back to quoted post9 May 2019, 09:46 AMBalanced_Gamer
A bit too much than it was irl.


I think it's been said many times but irl hardly matters at all for balance. If we went by IRL Axis would give up at the start of the game.
Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
Balanced_Gamer
9 May 2019, 12:20 PM
#113
avatar of Balanced_Gamer

Posts: 783

jump backJump back to quoted post9 May 2019, 12:11 PMLoliholic


I think it's been said many times but irl hardly matters at all for balance. If we went by IRL Axis would give up at the start of the game.


That is where balancing comes in, that is true. Axis armour would definitely real strong, (well they were but lets do it for the sake of balancing instead).

What I think Comet also needs is another different upgrade. A Vickers MG on top. Make it more potent against infantry costing 60 ammo. Make cost of Comet as I have suggested previously on comment #111. I do not think it deserves to be the way it costs now. A little too much I would say.
I enjoy Coh2. I want this game to be balanced as it can possibly be forukfukfusfusfokwokwsovietssovietsostheerostheer. Do not judge me, for my opinion is balanced. B-)

This is my playercard number if you are curious: https://www.coh2.org/ladders/playercard/steamid/76561198127033144

Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
Katitof
9 May 2019, 12:22 PM
#114
avatar of Katitof

Posts: 17914 | Subs: 8

jump backJump back to quoted post9 May 2019, 09:46 AMBalanced_Gamer
Maybe Armour needs some nerfing. A bit too much than it was irl.

Don't use IRL as argument.

If we were going with IRL stats, Comet would have BETTER penetration then Panther.
jump backJump back to quoted post25 Nov 2015, 11:09 AM$nuffy
Maybe it's 'cause the Axis players aren't a bunch of forum crybabies, and they keep their cool and fight the uphill battle, unlike some of their "allied" counterparts.
Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
distrofio
9 May 2019, 20:15 PM
#115
avatar of distrofio

Posts: 2358

How to answer a IRL argument:

jump backJump back to quoted post9 May 2019, 12:22 PMKatitof
...If we were going with IRL stats, Comet would have BETTER penetration then Panther.

"IRL is deprecated towards better game balance" and keeps ontopic.

on the other side
jump backJump back to quoted post9 May 2019, 12:11 PMLoliholic
I think it's been said many times but irl hardly matters at all for balance. If we went by IRL Axis would give up at the start of the game.

"making things absurd" only makes the argument absurd. It can be true but adds nothing.

IRL could only add flavour to the game, only after a balance check is done.
If someone gets offended, i didnt mean to, im just setting up a benchmark to use IRL arguments as they should.

Somehow COH2 got very messed up with the IRL department, something that VCoH was a lot tidier.

Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
WingZero
10 May 2019, 19:51 PM
#116
avatar of WingZero

Posts: 1484

I do like the idea of reduced reload time for the Comet!
Playercard of WingZero

4v4: Pstreak: - 1with STALKER ★★★, -NSO-Sasha, & Happy Camper
4v4: Pstreak: + 2with -NSO-Sasha, Happy Camper, & -NSO- HitzeLockdown
4v4: Pstreak: + 2with -NSO-Sasha, Happy Camper, & -NSO- HitzeLockdown
4v4: Pstreak: - 2with -NSO-Sasha, Happy Camper, & -NSO- HitzeLockdown


Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
blancat
11 May 2019, 02:54 AM
#117
avatar of blancat

Posts: 810

if comet need some buff,


reduce scatter vs AI, add top mounted MG will be needed

Now Comet has no advantage compared to Churchill
Reply Reply Multi Quote Reply Reply
PAGES (6)down
New topic New topic     Upload replay New Reply
1 user is browsing this thread: 1 guest
COH2.ORG » Forums » Parlor Room » COH2 Central » COH2 Balance » Comet tank has been too nerfed.

Livestreams

tightrope
 New Zealand 61
BadmanLarry
 United States 17
Velmarg
 unknown 4
Statement
 Netherlands 2

Ladders Top 10

UKF
USF
OKW
SOV
OST
1v1
2v2
3v3
4v4
  • #
    Steam Alias
    W
    L
    %
    Streak
Data provided by Relic Relic Entertainment

Replay highlight

Top Tier Teams
VS
  • U.S. Forces flag cblanco ★
  • The British Forces flag 보드카 중대
  • Oberkommando West flag VonManteuffel
  • Ostheer flag Heartless Jäger
Einhoven Country
Einhoven Country Honor
Honor it
11
 Download
Download
1266
uploaded by XXxxHeartlessxxXX

Board Info

579 users are online: 579 guests
3 posts in the last 24h
13 posts in the last week
32 posts in the last month
Registered members: 50074
Welcome our newest member, GeorgiadfHess
Most online: 2043 users on 29 Oct 2023, 01:04 AM