Login

russian armor

Russians on Western Front? Really?

PAGES (7)down
29 Mar 2014, 04:58 AM
#21
avatar of Mr. Someguy

Posts: 4928

I don't care for realism. I really don't. This game is already very unrealistic in many ways. Who cares if it's some what unrealistic, I'm worried that balance would be completely screwed in the future.
Well adding Italians won't make balance any better or worse regardless of portrayal, so I'm not sure why you come in here with that.
29 Mar 2014, 05:18 AM
#22
avatar of Volsky

Posts: 344

You'd have to sacrifice quite a bit of historical accuracy if you want Italy as a competent faction in CoH2. Italian equipment and vehicles were low quality compared to the Allies, and very poor quality compared to Germany's. Italy's primary tank, portrayed accurately, would struggle against the current T-70. Their strongest tank was on-par with modern (1944) medium tanks, and was never very rare and not used by them.

Not only that, but by the time the game takes place (1944), Italy was in a state of civil war, with the fascist side (including their military) propped up entirely by Nazi Germany. By this point, German Soldiers considered the Italians useless for anything but anti-partisan duty.


Eh...I would venture to say that the German's opinion of them was probably correct, unless we're talking about Alpini or Paracadutisti.

The Italians would probably be more at home as a new commander with support options rather than a whole faction...unless we want to start flinging soaked cardboard-armored and 47mm cannon-armed tanks at the Soviets.
29 Mar 2014, 06:28 AM
#23
avatar of MarcoRossolini

Posts: 1042

What about Romanian or Hungarian units? Though ofc they're be useless for the Western germans...
29 Mar 2014, 07:17 AM
#24
avatar of Svalbard SD

Posts: 327


Who cares as long as it is fun i dont care if russians didnt fight in Ardennes in reality.

We do.
29 Mar 2014, 07:17 AM
#25
avatar of CPU - Full Retard

Posts: 5

How about simply changing skins for Allies when they end up with US/Russian armies mixed ? Just like America's Army, where you always see yourself and your teammates as "the good guys", Russian players could see their US allies with Russian skin, and vice-versa for the US players. You know, something like T34 <=> Sherman, US Riflemen <=> Conscripts, etc..., only skin and speech accent could be affected.
29 Mar 2014, 08:10 AM
#26
avatar of Mr. Someguy

Posts: 4928

How about simply changing skins for Allies when they end up with US/Russian armies mixed ? Just like America's Army, where you always see yourself and your teammates as "the good guys", Russian players could see their US allies with Russian skin, and vice-versa for the US players. You know, something like T34 <=> Sherman, US Riflemen <=> Conscripts, etc..., only skin and speech accent could be affected.


I actually think that would be really cool, but it wouldn't work for things like Maxims.
29 Mar 2014, 12:50 PM
#27
avatar of Senseo1990

Posts: 317

Campaign will be focused on American/Germans western front.


There wont be any campaign.

On Topic:

Yes mixed allied factions is a horrible in my opinion. Ostheer and the OKW fighting together can make sense but will probably OP if US/Sov teams are not possible so mixed german factions will have to be taken out as well.

Relic stated a lot of times that they are trying to create a somewhat authentic (not necessarily realistic) experience. "Immersion" has always been part of Relics idea for the game (at least I did read that in an interview a while ago as far as I remember). This will utterly destroy that immersion.

The solution is simple but will split the playerbase (and will have an impact on the leaderboards): Let players choose if they want to be matched up against mixed teams or not.

For me there are things that im okay with concerning authenticity:

- Rare vehicles roaming the battlefield (Ostwinds)

- US forces fighting on soviet maps/soviet forces fighting on western front maps (though some kind of mechanic that replaces t34 wrecks with sherman wrecks and vice versa depending on which factions are involved would certainly be great)

-Ostheer fighting Americans/Soviets fighting the OKW

-Ostheer+OKW team fighting American-only team OR soviet-only team(though probably too unbalanced to allow for automatch)

-Obviously the unrealistic gameplay mechanics

But having IS2 tanks fighting alongside US Airborne rangers? That is too much imo. I dont need a perfectly authentic game but something that I feel has still something to do with the actual WW2.
29 Mar 2014, 12:53 PM
#28
avatar of Senseo1990

Posts: 317

How about simply changing skins for Allies when they end up with US/Russian armies mixed ? Just like America's Army, where you always see yourself and your teammates as "the good guys", Russian players could see their US allies with Russian skin, and vice-versa for the US players. You know, something like T34 <=> Sherman, US Riflemen <=> Conscripts, etc..., only skin and speech accent could be affected.


While certainly a great idea I see quite a few problems with it:

1) It will cause confusion for a lot of players ("Is that a conscript-conscript or a riflemen-conscript now?")

2) Its a lot of extra work for Relic

3) Some units cant be easily converted. Katyusha-> Calliope?
29 Mar 2014, 13:08 PM
#29
avatar of HansGoneInsane

Posts: 42

I dont get what all the fuzz is about. The expansion will be great, I am sure about that. I think that many people that complain about Soviets and Americans teaming up, simply don't like the Soviets. They think Soviets are "evil" and that you can't match something "evil" with something "good". These people just take the historical accruracy as a pretense.

I can't wait for the two new factions joining the battlefield.
29 Mar 2014, 13:13 PM
#30
avatar of Burts

Posts: 1702

I dont get what all the fuzz is about. The expansion will be great, I am sure about that. I think that many people that complain about Soviets and Americans teaming up, simply don't like the Soviets. They think Soviets are "evil" and that you can't match something "evil" with something "good". These people just take the historical accruracy as a pretense.

I can't wait for the two new factions joining the battlefield.





what? Are you insane?

No, i don't like sovs+ americans because its completely ahistorical.


I'm also excited for the new factions. I can't wait to play as soviets againts the new german faction.
What im not looking forward to is sovs+ americans in one team game.
29 Mar 2014, 13:13 PM
#31
avatar of Muad'Dib

Posts: 368



There wont be any campaign.

On Topic:

Yes mixed allied factions is a horrible in my opinion. Ostheer and the OKW fighting together can make sense but will probably OP if US/Sov teams are not possible so mixed german factions will have to be taken out as well.

Relic stated a lot of times that they are trying to create a somewhat authentic (not necessarily realistic) experience. "Immersion" has always been part of Relics idea for the game (at least I did read that in an interview a while ago as far as I remember). This will utterly destroy that immersion.

The solution is simple but will split the playerbase (and will have an impact on the leaderboards): Let players choose if they want to be matched up against mixed teams or not.

For me there are things that im okay with concerning authenticity:

- Rare vehicles roaming the battlefield (Ostwinds)

- US forces fighting on soviet maps/soviet forces fighting on western front maps (though some kind of mechanic that replaces t34 wrecks with sherman wrecks and vice versa depending on which factions are involved would certainly be great)

-Ostheer fighting Americans/Soviets fighting the OKW

-Ostheer/OKW fighting Americans OR soviets (though probably too unbalanced to allow for automatch)

-Obviously the unrealistic gameplay mechanics

But having IS2 tanks fighting alongside US Airborne rangers? That is too much imo. I dont need a perfectly authentic game but something that I feel has still something to do with the actual WW2.


This, precisely. I would still play it, but I'd have preferred more Eastern front armies.
29 Mar 2014, 13:16 PM
#32
avatar of Senseo1990

Posts: 317

I dont get what all the fuzz is about. The expansion will be great, I am sure about that. I think that many people that complain about Soviets and Americans teaming up, simply don't like the Soviets. They think Soviets are "evil" and that you can't match something "evil" with something "good". These people just take the historical accruracy as a pretense.

I can't wait for the two new factions joining the battlefield.


Thats a pretty heavy accusation youre making there. I wonder where youre getting that idea from to be honest.

Furthermore its not like the people who complain about mixed factions dislike the expansion as a whole. i cant wait for the expansion either but I simply dislike this aspect/this design decision.

Its obviously not a problem for everyone, wether a change concerning this "issue"is necessary simply depends on the amount of people who hate it.
29 Mar 2014, 13:18 PM
#33
avatar of Affe

Posts: 578

jump backJump back to quoted post29 Mar 2014, 13:13 PMBurts





what? Are you insane?

No, i don't like sovs+ americans because its completely ahistorical.


I'm also excited for the new factions. I can't wait to play as soviets againts the new german faction.
What im not looking forward to is sovs+ americans in one team game.

Relic said you can even make a match soviets vs USA............
29 Mar 2014, 13:19 PM
#34
avatar of Burts

Posts: 1702



There wont be any campaign.

On Topic:

Yes mixed allied factions is a horrible in my opinion. Ostheer and the OKW fighting together can make sense but will probably OP if US/Sov teams are not possible so mixed german factions will have to be taken out as well.

Relic stated a lot of times that they are trying to create a somewhat authentic (not necessarily realistic) experience. "Immersion" has always been part of Relics idea for the game (at least I did read that in an interview a while ago as far as I remember). This will utterly destroy that immersion.

The solution is simple but will split the playerbase (and will have an impact on the leaderboards): Let players choose if they want to be matched up against mixed teams or not.

For me there are things that im okay with concerning authenticity:

- Rare vehicles roaming the battlefield (Ostwinds)

- US forces fighting on soviet maps/soviet forces fighting on western front maps (though some kind of mechanic that replaces t34 wrecks with sherman wrecks and vice versa depending on which factions are involved would certainly be great)

-Ostheer fighting Americans/Soviets fighting the OKW

-Ostheer/OKW fighting Americans OR soviets (though probably too unbalanced to allow for automatch)

-Obviously the unrealistic gameplay mechanics

But having IS2 tanks fighting alongside US Airborne rangers? That is too much imo. I dont need a perfectly authentic game but something that I feel has still something to do with the actual WW2.



Honestly, i don't think soviets fighting the new OKW ruins immersion. I mean they are just germans, however sovs+ americans does.
29 Mar 2014, 13:20 PM
#35
avatar of RuberGruber

Posts: 39

Love the idea, game just got a lot more interesting for me but I'm never been one for complete historical accuracy. Kinda find that idea a bit too stiff and stale to work with.
29 Mar 2014, 13:21 PM
#36
avatar of Raindrop

Posts: 105

How about simply changing skins for Allies when they end up with US/Russian armies mixed ? Just like America's Army, where you always see yourself and your teammates as "the good guys", Russian players could see their US allies with Russian skin, and vice-versa for the US players. You know, something like T34 <=> Sherman, US Riflemen <=> Conscripts, etc..., only skin and speech accent could be affected.


I like the idea, would simply be soviet leand lease comander. Rifle men could be strelki with M1 Garnads getting replaced with Svt-40's and bazookas being simply lend lease bazookas. Without stat changes. Same could be done with maps Semoski getting some of its building replaced to look like Semois.

Tho it would be alot of work, so its probably not going to happen. So the only option will be US Army + Red army vs Ostheer + Westheer. Or they go 2 US vs 2 Westheer, and 2 Soviet vs 2 Ostheer, since 2 Soviet or 2 US-Army vs Ostheer + Westheer would cause a lot of complains.

Imo it would have been better if they would have just added one new faction the US-Army. And kept a new Wehrmacht fraction for a next expansion. Btw OK West should be renamed to Army Group West or Westheer imo.
29 Mar 2014, 13:29 PM
#37
avatar of The_Riddler

Posts: 336

jump backJump back to quoted post28 Mar 2014, 21:48 PMherrtin
don't ruin the realism just because u want bigger player base


CoH doesnt come near realism, therefore, exchanging some of the historical accuracy that is still part of the game for additional players is a valid compromise. As long as it remains Axis versus Allies, there is enough realism to uphold it as a WW2 rts.
29 Mar 2014, 13:29 PM
#38
avatar of Zupadupadude

Posts: 618

jump backJump back to quoted post29 Mar 2014, 13:18 PMAffe

Relic said you can even make a match soviets vs USA............


Yeah, in a custom match. You can already play Soviets vs Soviets if you make a custom match. Do not panic, they won't do Ami's vs Soviets in automatch.
29 Mar 2014, 13:49 PM
#39
avatar of Sait

Posts: 27

While were at it, wheres the love for the canadians! hahaha.. yeah you can guess i don't like the back to western front idea..
29 Mar 2014, 13:54 PM
#40
avatar of Senseo1990

Posts: 317

jump backJump back to quoted post29 Mar 2014, 13:19 PMBurts

Honestly, i don't think soviets fighting the new OKW ruins immersion. I mean they are just germans, however sovs+ americans does.


Oh I think I caused a missunderstanding: I totally agree: Im fine with OKW vs soviets and Ostheer vs US as well.
PAGES (7)down
1 user is browsing this thread: 1 guest

Livestreams

unknown 11
United States 24
Russian Federation 10
unknown 1

Ladders Top 10

  • #
    Steam Alias
    W
    L
    %
    Streak
Data provided by Relic Relic Entertainment

Replay highlight

VS
  • U.S. Forces flag cblanco ★
  • The British Forces flag 보드카 중대
  • Oberkommando West flag VonManteuffel
  • Ostheer flag Heartless Jäger
uploaded by XXxxHeartlessxxXX

Board Info

1096 users are online: 1096 guests
1 post in the last 24h
9 posts in the last week
27 posts in the last month
Registered members: 50008
Welcome our newest member, Goynet40
Most online: 2043 users on 29 Oct 2023, 01:04 AM