Profile of Darkpiatre

I did. It was largely ignored because this community (especially those who still post here) is now 90% Axis mains.

Sure bro, you're the best bro!

Say what you want about the Tiger, the Pershing got it much worse. Honestly what they did to heavies in the last balance patch was such a lazy thing to do. They just basically changed all three multi-role heavies the same way without regard to how each unit fits into each faction.

Totaly right bro!

I would have prefer to stay on the previous thread about it, there was at least some interesting data to avoid the inevitable "learn to play scrub" or "but the others heavies too got shred".

The Tiger is a joke and giving it to the OKW made it harder to balance, especially in 1vs1, so is the OKW Tiger a different unit which could be refer as "Command Tiger" or it is just a regular Tiger with an ability?

The Tiger Ace is even more a joke, and it was already true for a long time.

Both tank have cancerous gameplay in long run, able to wipe vetted infantry like nothing. I'm with Creativename, if it can't be balance, it is better to nerf both into the ground.

The Tiger got a special treatment with the 20% scatter at vet 2 removed. Plus if I remember correctly, the AOE nerf was the exact same flat amount for all heavies, which represent a bigger impact on the Tiger proportionaly since it has the lowest (AOE) of the 3(IS,Pershing,Tiger).

Revert the Scatter and we should be fine.

And I'm more willing to take into acount the stats given mounth ago rather than a vid.

They provided much more than you have. You haven't provided anything at all

First I'm not the one coming out with a thread asking for a nerf of an ability without showing any kind of evidence of why it would have to be so, if you want people to reply correctly at any of your request you have to be precise and show them a minimum of reflexion over why you came up with this idea, why they should follow this idea, and the whole illustrated with some example or numbers.

Second,here there was just a lot of players motivated by their emotions more than by their reason calling for a nerf based on their subjective experience more than any concrete reflexion. Despite the lack of any evidence I provided example and even illustated it more than necessary to help some understand.

What are you trying to say? It makes no sense to compare those abilities and it only works against your point, as I just showed you

Can you answer the question? Why does it need to be uncounterable? Why can't we just replace it with a recon plane?

Let's keep it simple:

Il-2 Bomb: have the ability to destroy ------> Need a drawback -----> red flares+vision to cast

Flares: don't have this ability to destroy -----> No need of a drawback -----> no need of those.

Now why is it uncounterable?

Planes: Cover a wider area, last longer, can reveal invisible units -----> Drawback: can be destroyed.

Flares: Smaller area, can't reveal invisible units ect... -------> No need of such drawback.

Those ability are different and flares are unique, and I'm sure what motivates people to a nerf is more than this unique ability from a single commander is specific to the OKW than anything else.

Why can't we just replace it with recon plane? Read Previous post about reco units of the OKW and recent nerf of the IR-HT, you'll understand that without making it a good reco, nerfing the only real reco of the OKW isn't a good idea at all.