Is COH2 broken?

Jump back to quoted post23 Jun 2015, 23:08 PMScifiroel

Well it's not a problem per sé, it's more of an observation that keeps being confirmed because it just keeps happening.

Besides, observation is not dogmatic, if it stops happening I will adjust my view. So that's not dogmatic.

Having a general "rule" or "assumption" and sticking with it no matter what your own observation tells you is dogmatic. That's not what I'm doing here.

I originally also had the assumption that axis was generally stronger than allies but with what has happened to me recently has changed that belief (I'm not saying axis is always weaker than allies but they are certainly not stronger, at least not anymore). In other words, I experienced something and adjusted my view accordingly and that's anything but dogmatic.

Jump back to quoted post23 Jun 2015, 22:51 PMScifiroel

Than why does this keep happening? Why do I get swarmed as axis every single time, why do I swarm the axis as allies every single time why do my random teammates who play axis say the same thing I've been saying every single time? Explain that! If there is really nothing going on then why is it the same thing over and over again? I refuse to believe that that is a coincedence. It feels like a pattern. Besides, majority is not always right. Often majority get's stuck in dogma's and absolutes. Most people think like this for example: "this thing is always true" and then base their reasoning on that. In this case the notion "axis is always OP in large teamgames" is the center of most people's reasoning without taking enough variables into consideration.

Jump back to quoted post23 Jun 2015, 23:24 PMTheDesertFox

You make a good point, often the majority can be very wrong.

But this is a specific case here.

This is an issue of personal performance. I cannot explain why this or why that, without concrete facts (ie, a replay...).

If you supply a replay to prove your point, the problem will be solved because then we will have the necessary facts to reach a conclusion.

Right now, you are 'claiming' xyz... yet, it is known that people greatly exaggerate their own experiences.

Jump back to quoted post23 Jun 2015, 21:59 PMScifiroel

That's it i'm not using this forum any longer! I haven't been here long but I'm done being isulted by people calling me "ill informed" and sometimes even "stupid". I have these impressions about the game for a reason and I hate not being taken seriously!

goodbey people!

Jump back to quoted post23 Jun 2015, 23:28 PMScifiroel

Well, I may be able to provide a few replays when I play soviet and win, I haven't saved my axis defeat replays though... I may supply them tommorow, right now I have to go to bed. And yes, I really do have to. It's 1:30 am right now in Belgium, look it up if you don't believe me, I'm not just saying that to get out of posting replays, honestly.

Jump back to quoted post23 Jun 2015, 15:45 PMJadame!

Wehr snipers uncounterable.

Jump back to quoted post23 Jun 2015, 20:44 PMScifiroel

L2p, L2p, L2p.... come on people, none of you have seen me play so just shut up about the L2p, it's very easy to say that when you haven't seen me play. That is not helping at all. Besides, I'm not really losing, I'm actually winning, but only with one faction, a faction I used to suck with.

Jump back to quoted post24 Jun 2015, 13:22 PMJawohl?

l2p

Jump back to quoted post23 Jun 2015, 23:08 PMScifiroel

Well it's not a problem per sé, it's more of an observation that keeps being confirmed because it just keeps happening.

Besides, observation is not dogmatic, if it stops happening I will adjust my view. So that's not dogmatic.

Having a general "rule" or "assumption" and sticking with it no matter what your own observation tells you is dogmatic. That's not what I'm doing here.

I originally also had the assumption that axis was generally stronger than allies but with what has happened to me recently has changed that belief (I'm not saying axis is always weaker than allies but they are certainly not stronger, at least not anymore). In other words, I experienced something and adjusted my view accordingly and that's anything but dogmatic.

Jump back to quoted post24 Jun 2015, 13:35 PMKatitof

Lets theoretically assume your observations are correct FOR YOU.

You see this very frequently, but vast majority of player population don't.

The possible causes can be three:

-You always have a bad luck and play against better team, which is unlikely even if the matchmaking would be completely random.

-Your allies are always bad, which is unlikely for the same reason as the above.

-You are bad.

Going with the 3rd option makes most sense as it would mean you frequently see yourself being overwhelmed as most likely you are the weakest link in your team, which would explain you getting ass whooped despite statistics saying blatantly that axis is OP in the bracket you play.

Case
Solved
/thread

Jump back to quoted post24 Jun 2015, 13:22 PMJawohl?

l2p

Jump back to quoted post23 Jun 2015, 23:37 PMpigsoup

maybe you are not being dogmatic generally but you are right now.

your observation wasn't dogmatic. it is your view or "assumption" that you drew from your observation/experience that is.

stats on the paid_player's page and overwhelming majority disagree with you, yet you aren't even budging a bit. and the fact that you chose to fault the game from the get go says a lot.

Jump back to quoted post24 Jun 2015, 14:56 PMpugzii

Why does this thread still exist? seriously.

Its 1 guy who refuses to budge even in the face of pure statistics and the entire forum user base who disagree.

Jump back to quoted post24 Jun 2015, 14:59 PMScifiroel

I have made a forum post about this before and there I did budge. I took in account their advice and still the same thing kept happening. What does that tell you? I'm not dogmatic in my assumption because I took in account all of this once before and it didn't change anything. Which makes the conclusion pretty easy to draw. I don't want to blame the game, I have said that before and I meant that. But everything that has happened lately has got me thinking otherwise.

Jump back to quoted post23 Jun 2015, 23:28 PMScifiroel

Well, I may be able to provide a few replays when I play soviet and win, I haven't saved my axis defeat replays though... I may supply them tommorow, right now I have to go to bed. And yes, I really do have to. It's 1:30 am right now in Belgium, look it up if you don't believe me, I'm not just saying that to get out of posting replays, honestly.

•  
  

  0

  VS

  Scifiroel JasonStrife Taxxim

  Valkyrie raffler?

  one

  by: Scifiroel map: Angermuende

  1

  -

•  
  

  0

  VS

  Scifiroel

  two

  by: Scifiroel map: Lazenrath Ambush

  1

  -

•  
  

  0

  VS

  Scifiroel Mirage 2000 Love it !!!

  -;0AB8G=K9 ?>OA

  three

  by: Scifiroel map: General Mud

  1

  -

•  
  

  0

  VS

  Scifiroel Grandpapy

  White Widow

  four

  by: Scifiroel map: Lazenrath Ambush

  1

  -

Jump back to quoted post24 Jun 2015, 15:38 PMScifiroel

These are a few replays. I'm not entirely sure they are the correct ones because since the last patch of yesterday I can't view them anymore.
I don't know if any of you can still view them but I'll post them anyway. I renamed them going from 1 to 4, 1 being the most recent, 4 being the oldest.

Also keep in mind, I never said I was "the best player ever", I just said that I'm not a noob. I think I have earned it to say that I have left the so called "noob stage" behind.

•  
  

  0

  VS

  Scifiroel JasonStrife Taxxim

  Valkyrie raffler?

  one

  by: Scifiroel map: Angermuende

  1

  -

•  
  

  0

  VS

  Scifiroel

  two

  by: Scifiroel map: Lazenrath Ambush

  1

  -

•  
  

  0

  VS

  Scifiroel Mirage 2000 Love it !!!

  -;0AB8G=K9 ?>OA

  three

  by: Scifiroel map: General Mud

  1

  -

•  
  

  0

  VS

  Scifiroel Grandpapy

  White Widow

  four

  by: Scifiroel map: Lazenrath Ambush

  1

  -