Your metaphor is confused and esoteric.
"I, as a professional "X" am not allowed to be considered knowledgeable on what counters "X"."
This makes no sense.
[edit]
Or an even simpler explanation.
I play Rock, Paper, Scissors.
I always throw Rock.
I always beat Scissors.
I always lose to Paper.
Based on what you have just read, Am I knowledgeable in not only what Rock can do, but what Rock is vulnerable to?
You think you are intelligent when you are actually confused. Let me guess, you're a philosophy student?
It's very simple: someone who has never done X cannot educate other people how to do X.
If you've never had to counter Maxim spam, your opinion about how to counter it is worthless. It's not rocket science. Ask your professor for help.
P.S. Look up esoteric in a dictionary, it doesn't mean what you think it means.