1) Dont think thats necesarry
5) 100% agreed,
There is one thing that I dont often see mentioned: IS take eternity to vet up. U can have them in combat for 5 mins nonstop and theyll still hardly reach vet1 the cromewell has more pen than p4 so how is the gun bad ?
|
|
he will never gives his opinions that's the trick vipper, he only plays the passive aggressive role, he knows he won't be banned for that |
Penetration. It's got a similar gun to the Firefly.
The Firefly is a long range tank with a very slow fire rate. If it's not leveraging its range, it'll lose to a standard medium.
The Panther's fast, has good penetration and bonus health, but awful AI. It can't snipe, but doesn't lose to enemy tanks if a brawl happens. A Panther-like Comet would have the same.
then their role would overlap, and u would need to increase the cost of the comet or remove the comet AI |
|
is this a joke ?
1 it's one of the most powerful upgrade there is, it does not increase cost of the unit, u don't pay munitions on each squad (like weapons) and reinforce cost stays the same
2 no at nades are good on RE if u want at nades on IS just pick the tank hunter doc
3 gamon bomb can be used by every IS, penal have to buy the upgrade each time
4 the MG does it's job, the main canon is AT only
5 cromwell is fine for his price, it has more pen than p4 and is super fast |
You'd have to drop the AI to Panther levels, yes. If it's got solid AI and solid AT with a little below Panther durability, it's a Pershing.
As for overlapping with the Firefly, I don't think it does. The Firefly is a very slow firing, fragile sniper tank. Snares have done a lot for it, but it's nevertheless a sniper which'll lose to a medium tank at close range. Even the Cromwell is better off in a brawl.
A Panther Comet could coexist with the Firefly in the same way the JP4 and Panther coexist. If anything, the Panther is favored over the JP4.
yes but what would u change ? pen does not make sense for the comet (fire fly exist) , accuracy is not a problem
either a little buff to the MGs or a 0.4 buff to reload at max |
|
The range it’s out of question
First we need to identify the problem
Is it too underwhelming for its cost ? Reduce it
It has difficult fighting medium tank ? More frontal armor or less reload speed
The AI is random ? Buff the MG |
I don't think that's true, hovering over it lists it as having an AOE of 8.4, so I have no idea how that is calculated. I think I'll stick to the listed numbers below.
I'm quite sure that the circle is the actual AOE u can check it by using artillery |
Im getting my stats from coh2db.com/stats.
There it lists p4 having 2.5 AOE with 6.5 scatter angle and the e8 has 2.0 AOE with 5 scatter angle. Where are you getting your info?
For the record I was looking at OKWs p4. OST p4 has a 2.5 AOE and 7.5 scatter.
SAME SITE BUT TO CHECK THE AOE u need to hover over the yellow point in the graf
it's 6,3 p4 and 6,8 e8 and as i said lower scatter means better |
Put E8 vs p4 vs a tank with any semblance of armour.
Furthermore p4 has 2.5 AOE with 6.5 scatter and e8 has 2 AOE with 5 scatter. Stop using "alternative facts" when saying E8 has bad AOE.
lol what are u on ?
P4 has 6,2 aoe and the way 8 has 6.5 , what u saw was the near aoe not the full one
Less scatter = better chance to hit |
|
guys u are all forgetting that the target entity is chosen at random, the sniper rifle will not target the lowest hp entity |
Katitof-2018 
Relic Entertainment
cblanco ★ 
보드카 중대 
VonManteuffel 
Heartless Jäger 
