New one is going to take some more balancing to get right, but it's a step in the right direction. Comparing it right now, when there's only been one minor tweak to it since it launched is unfair compared to the old OKW that was balanced and balanced for a year or more. Let it settle for a few more patches before making final judgement.
Few more patches and more of the community will have left/be fed up over Relic constantly shifting the game, completely quaking the balance and not addressing obsolete units and commanders. And thus, with the advent of constantly more DLC (as Relic needs to make money), it doesn't make any of the problems easier to solve. Imo, this game had potential, but was too intertwined with Meta game that there wasn't ever much room for strategy, flanking, and most importantly combined arms.
Imo, they should so what 4A games did with Metro 2033, combine both games, improving general mechanics, and vastly improving graphics. Company of heroes redux if you will