+1 for ciez's post.
I vote no. Too much RNG. It's so frustated when your loosing, half of your troops/tanks because of crashed planes for example.
Hm maybe it is harder to play, but i think watching is a more fun if there is RNG. Obviously 1 shotting a vet 3 Squad with full health should not happen. But as a fan i do not only want to watch a pure chess game. I want to watch the horror of one player getting 3 times bad luck - but still keeps fighting and (hopefully) wins by strong mind and even more skillfull strat.
In other words as a fan, i kind of like the tragedy. So RNG needs to get toned just a bit. But should not be negated. Do not forget, this is what Coh2 makes sepecial anyways.