Didn´t safe the replay. I tried using the Panther at max range though and moved it backwards. Thus it missed 2 shots. Also two generalist tanks shouldn´t really beat a specialist anti tank vehicle from the front - at least not at that cost for the Panther.
So 2 P4s shouldn't beat SU-85 upfront as well?
After all its two generalist tanks vs specialist anti tank vehicle from the front.
Don't you see how silly your statement is?
34/85s got as much hp and dps as panther, difference is with penetration, armor and range. If you put two of them, you get enough firepower to bring down a panther and you should as its much more fuel and menpower then panther costs. Panther have pretty much the same effective HP as 2 34/85s, but two 34/85s have twice the DPS.
Numbers are fine, don't overextend it and don't let it go without AT support unless you're flanking something, but 34/85s doesn't require flank. And last but not least, there is this little thing called mark target that will usually be used, so you're being put up against a much greater resources and a pair of strong units, don't expect that to end up well for you if you don't support and overextend.