I only know from an interview with a german veteran, that they would only record a target as killed/destroyed if it was actually burning or exploding.
Otherwhise they werent allowed to claim it as a kill.
___
Several of the examples I posted actually list two numbers, a "confirmed" one and a another "asumed" or "claimed" one.
I decided to go with the lowest listed numbers just to be sure.
Also I didnt list destroyed (AntiTank) Guns, which were counted seperately.
I'm sure there are cases of exaggeration by tank commanders or for propaganda reason, but I so far didnt find any sources indicating that it was any worse than on allied side
( But I once read the Americans were counting cars/trucks as kills ^^) |
I hope I can add to the topic with some numbers, if you got more acurate ones please link me to them, Im genuinely interessted.
Here is a list of all Soviet IS-2 aces I was able to track down:
followed by a list of some other soviet and german tank aces. Its ofcourse not a complete list.
I picked the overall best for the soviets, and the top commanders for the germans sorted by the vehicles they commanded. Because the clear majority of soviet aces were t-34 commanders, and on german side it seems to be more spread out, if you dont count the tigers.
__________________
1st lt. Lukanin Veniamin Grigorievich - 19 kills
- he commanded both an IS and a KV, I dont know how many kills he actually achieved commanding his IS -
Lyahov Pyotr T. - 9 kills
Reznikov Mihail - 8 kills
- actually a gunner not a tank commander -
1st lt. Galpyorn Vladimir I. - 6 kills
- + 14 guns -
lt. Hitzenko Ivan I. - 5 kills
lt. Boyko Alexandra L. - 5 kills
- fun fact: a woman -
_______
The most successful overall tank ace on soviet side:
1st lt. Lavrinenko Dmitriy Fyodorovich - 52 kills
- commanded a T-34(-76)-
After him come
lt. Kuchenkov M - 32,
Moiseyev N. - 31,
cap. Dyachenko N. - 31,
cap. Samohin Konstantin Mihaylovich - 30,
subcol. Burda Alexander Fyodorovich - 30 and
1st lt. Bochkovsky Vladimir Alexeyevich - 36
all commanded T-34s, for the most part atleast
________
Those guys as far as I know where the most successful soviet, even allied tank aces.
________
Overview of german tank aces:
In Panzer IVs
Strippel, Hans – 70
Riedel, Franz - 40
Kändler, Willi - 24
Kretzschmar, Willi/Willy - 15
In T-34s^^
Seibold, Emil – 69
In Panthers
Barkmann, Ernst - 82
Giese, Hans / Horst - 58
Malkomes, Hans - 24
StuGs
Spranz, Bodo - 76
Primozic, Hugo – 68
Brandner, Josef ("Sepp") - 66
Sauer, Konrad - 65
Jagdpanzer IV
Roy, Rudolf - 36
Nashorn
Ernst, Albert - 55
Ferdinand
Teriete, Heinrich – 22
Kretschmer, Franz – 21
Hetzer
Dallmeier, Josef - 50
Now the "fun" part,
Panzer VI Tiger
Knispel, Kurt – 168
Carius, Otto – 150
Bölter, Johannes (Hans) - 139
Wittmann, Michael - 138
Egger, Paul - 113
Rondorf, Heinrich - 106
Gärtner, Heinz – 103
Körner, Karl - 100
Kerscher, Albert – 100
Woll, Balthasar ("Bobby") - 100
[...] |