I now have 6, yes that is right 6 friends, who I play Guild Wars 2 with and have been trying to get them to come over and try COH2. All 6 of them have taken stock of the metacritic score and have decided NOT to buy even though I have told them to take no notice of it and that its a good game.
when CoH1 got a great metacritic score from both users and critics it was trumpeted by Relic and THQ as this great indicator of the game's quality.
CoH2 gets a lower score than SC2:WoL and SC2:HotS. And, users are just destroying CoH2 in their reviews while providing mixed reviews to SC2.
Now the fanboys claim, Metacritic is meaningless. Of course, you can not have it both ways.
I think Metacritic scores have some meaning to them. For 2006 Tech Levels CoH1 is far better than CoH2 (relative to 2013 tech levels). And the Metacritic scores have reflected this reality. The CoH1 campaign is much better as well. When CoH1 came out all RTS fans i knew and I reacted like.. "wow this is fucking awesome stuff". No one is saying "wow" about CoH2.
Here is a small anecdote:
The guy who owns Toronto's (most populous city in canada) best internet cafe states that "no one is playing CoH2"
"its all Dota2, LoL, SC2, WoW, GW2, and even Minecraft"
"when a gang of 10 guys comes in to play its always the games above... i do not even have CoH2 installed on any machines"
What can not be denied is the plummeting # of simultaneous CoH2 users on Steam.
Look for CoH2 to go on sale during Steam's "Super Summer Sale" that ends July 22.