Profile of Sturmpanther

Jump back to quoted post19 Oct 2017, 15:47 PMRosbone

A_E Should have put together a HYPE video that does a quick outline of each map! Woot!

Jump back to quoted post19 Oct 2017, 11:42 AMvasa1719

You whanna say that 3 penals istn spam ? So 3 obers wil be not spam ? 3 dhsk will be not spam ? 3 sutgs will be not spam ?

Jump back to quoted post19 Oct 2017, 08:05 AMSiphon X.

Some thoughts after reading through the rules for the scoring system again. It's too late for this now, I guess, but in case you want to do something similar in the future and be it for another game:

• There are only 4 batches of points to award per category (3x10, 1x20). Expect to see draws...
  
  
• Subdividing into categories and then picking map with the most points as the overall winner has an obvious drawback: It's very likely that not the best map overall will win, but instead the one which is only better than the other in its category.
  
  As an example: In category A we have maps 1, 2 and 3. Now, 1 might be okish, but 2 and 3 are clearly worse. It's likely that map 1 gets all points in this category. Now, in category B maps 4 and 5 are brilliant while 6 is still pretty good. So, points might be split between 4 and 5 while 6 won't get any. The overall winner then is the mediocre map 1, even though it might be worse than map 6.
  
  I guess it would be better to have one list only. Problem then is that you have only 4 batches of points to award, so the list won't be very meaningful. So, instead, why not having everybody award 1-10 points (or 1-20 for the tournament finalists) instead of the fixed 10 for their personal choice?
  
  Figure that the subdivision is meant to increase diversity in the mappool, assuming that e.g. urban maps will have a hard time competing with rural maps. However, even with the list you still could give out prizes or include the best maps for each category if that's a concern.
  
  
• The popular vote and the tourney is nice, but wouldn't it be better to close the community vote only after the tournament? Let's face it, there will be very few players that actually take a look at all 10 maps or even a fraction thereof. However, during the tournament (which will be casted, right?) they might at least get an impression of them and thus have a potentially better basis (and more incentive) for their vote.
  

Jump back to quoted post18 Oct 2017, 15:19 PMaerafield

Show Spoiler

Jump back to quoted post18 Oct 2017, 14:22 PM|GB| The Hooligan486

Very fun game, double usf on north moscow outskirts against ost and okw on south.
GG , enjoyed this game a lot