I'm afraid I can't agree on this suggestion since the Cromwell already has an amazing rate of fire when it fully vets. Might get OP.
cromwell: (note the avg reload time is using the current live value)
vet 1: smoke round recharge time decreased to 10 seconds from 15
vet 2: +35 % turret speed; .70 modifier on reload time (4.06 avg)
vet 3: +20% top speed, acceleration, deceleration, and hull rotation speed; .80 modifier on reload time (3.248)
Panzer 4:
vet 1: blitz
vet 2: +30% armor (180 to 234), +40% turret speed
vet 3: .70 modifier on reload time (3.85 avg); +20% hull rotation speed; +10% acceleration and deceleration.
panzer 4 get armor boost in stead of cromwell's double reload boost.
However, if we want to avoid stacking bonus, I propose the following veterancy for the cromwell:
cromwell
default size to 20 (which is different from the 18 I originally suggested)
reload time to 5.5-5.1 (5.3 avg)
pe to 90/100/110
vet1: no change
vet2: .85 modifier on incoming accuracy (effectively 17 target size ),+35 % turret speed
vet3: no change. (5.3 avg become 3.71 avg)
this would provide the cromwell with both defensive and offensive bonus in its veterancy, instead of double downing on the reload.
all this "improvement-OP" forget the Commander upgrade and vet levels. They compare a fresh build cromwell with a vet 3 p4.
the reload time value I posted in my original post is that of a vet 0 cromwell and vet 0 panzer 4. They are factual and easily provable and discovered.
I like this, though I would advocate for leaving the short range penetration as-is to emphasize its role as a flanker and compliment the FF's tulips. Out of curiosity, what are the chances of either P4 hitting the Crom with size 18?
maybe something like 90/100/120 ?
45% - 90%
Cromwell Should have Coaxial and Hull MG Profile Like T-34 ?
Buff the MG damage, I don't think there's a more painful thing in CoH2 than chasing a Wehr sniper down with a cromwell only for it to miss 3-4 shots and then retreat into base under a faust screen.
Yes this happened to me and I'm mad, T-34/76 or P4 would murder an ill positioned sniper in seconds. Comet seems to be just as useless at hitting things, buff MG damage on both tanks.
stronger mg doesn't really suit the cromwell. The mg's 35 range doesn't really mesh well with the sight bonus from the tank commander.
The mg also require the unit to remain stationary for full effect. The cromwell's high top speed and acceleration is better suited for shoot and scoot.