I'd say the CoH2 competitive scene is quite healthy and I'm bold enough to say it will surpass CoH1's heights in a few months.
Depends on your definition of 'competitive scene' and 'healthy' i guess.
I rarely play CoH2 myself and its save to say that i am a bad player. I know less about micro and macro and i don´t know the current meta. But if i decide to play some hours on a sunday i can reach the top 100 without a problem, even while losing about 50% of my games. I did this three times now. You couldn't do that in CoH1. It was simply impossible. Also ididn't play for about two months and i just dropped from position 100 to 150 during this time. Meaning the ladder is more or less static.
Next point: replays. No offence but 98% of CoH2´s replays uploaded on this site aren´t entertaining. There are just a few players who actually got a enjoyable playstyle. I can´t even remeber the last time i saw a entertaing 2v2 game. I´d really like to cast them but none uploads such replays. There are way less good replays then CoH1 offered even in the state of decay following the steam migration.
An other aspect are the threads here in coh2.org. I miss discussed between competitive thinking players. Guys who play the game to win, guys who want to improve and dicussion about the meta game, about possible strategys, about ways how to improve micro and macro management. There are a few interessting threads each month but thats about it.
IpKai, i really wish you are right. I really do. I´d would be great for this side, great for Relic, greate for me as commentator but from what i can see i can´t share your optimistic estimate.
Still is interesting to me that some posters in this thread seem to imply that coh2 is a game with a low skill cap that is super easy/lacks competition/no one good plays...
CieZ, you are one of the guys who´s posts i usually enjoy to read. But seriously, CoH2´s competitive scene is smaller than CoH1´s scene was. Especially mid skill players are totally missing. And no, i don´t want to attack the CoH2 players. In every game offering the same chances to all players the better player will usually win. You need a different skill set for CoH2 then you needed for CoH1 but CoH2 is not easier to play.
I really hope we can overcome this hate some day. I am tired of it.