Login

russian armor

Ostheer Grenadiers

19 Aug 2016, 08:20 AM
#21
avatar of tightrope
Senior Caster Badge
Patrion 39

Posts: 1194 | Subs: 29

They should change it so you can only pick up 1 LMG from weapon racks and tweak the performance of those LMG to make it fair.
19 Aug 2016, 10:26 AM
#22
avatar of thedarkarmadillo

Posts: 5279

allies are allowed to walk around without getting suppressed!! but axis infantry must die asap

the quality of your posts is astoundingly bad and you should feel bad
19 Aug 2016, 11:30 AM
#23
avatar of adamírcz

Posts: 955

They should change it so you can only pick up 1 LMG from weapon racks and tweak the performance of those LMG to make it fair.

Sounds like a solution...and a good one
19 Aug 2016, 12:22 PM
#24
avatar of suuuhdude

Posts: 44

jump backJump back to quoted post19 Aug 2016, 07:18 AMKatitof

Why?
This horse is so dead and beaten up there is just a crater in the place it was.

Nothing will change, because that isn't how the game is balanced.
EOT and /thread really.



:snfPeter::snfPeter::snfPeter::snfPeter::snfPeter:
:snfPeter::snfPeter:
:snfPeter::snfPeter::snfPeter::snfPeter::snfPeter:


Conscripts atleast have utility and good durability at vet3. Doctrinal ppsh is really good on them.

Give conscripts dp28 upgrade with t4. That way grens can upgrade g43s doctrinally. I see no issues with this. Then every faction has equal options. Cons and grens would finally be able to not get outscaled as hell if they chose certain doctrines.
19 Aug 2016, 12:25 PM
#25
avatar of Katitof

Posts: 17914 | Subs: 8



Conscripts atleast have utility and good durability at vet3. Doctrinal ppsh is really good on them.

Give conscripts dp28 upgrade with t4. That way grens can upgrade g43s doctrinally. I see no issues with this. Then every faction has equal options. Cons and grens would finally be able to not get outscaled as hell if they chose certain doctrines.

You want to go this way then?

Ok.

Grens have utility, therefore can't compete against tommies or rifles, doctrinally they have even more utility on form of map hack and good all-range weapon(in case 240mp60muni squad being weaker then 280mp120/140muni squads for whatever reason isn't enough of an argument for you).
19 Aug 2016, 12:51 PM
#26
avatar of dasheepeh

Posts: 2115 | Subs: 1

jump backJump back to quoted post19 Aug 2016, 12:25 PMKatitof

You want to go this way then?

Ok.

Grens have utility, therefore can't compete against tommies or rifles, doctrinally they have even more utility on form of map hack and good all-range weapon(in case 240mp60muni squad being weaker then 280mp120/140muni squads for whatever reason isn't enough of an argument for you).


but tommies and rifles have plenty of utility as well?

requires a crawler and you remembering that this ability even exists

so how do you deal with main line infantry then?


19 Aug 2016, 13:02 PM
#27
avatar of suuuhdude

Posts: 44

jump backJump back to quoted post19 Aug 2016, 12:25 PMKatitof

You want to go this way then?

Ok.

Grens have utility, therefore can't compete against tommies or rifles, doctrinally they have even more utility on form of map hack and good all-range weapon(in case 240mp60muni squad being weaker then 280mp120/140muni squads for whatever reason isn't enough of an argument for you).


A 240 mp squad still loses to a 280 mp squad. Hasn't changed. (Btw g43 offers no long range dps boost, simply turns the weakest baseline squad in game into a brawler against allied squads that have more dps in short-mid. MAKES TOTAL SENSE LOL, g43 is a joke upgrade by itself) a 240mp 105 muni squad (lmg42+g43) STILL LOSES to a 280 mp 120 muni squad. Because for one, g43s no dps long range, still lower dps than a bar rifle. Doctrinal while allies dual equip non doc.

The matchup doesnt change at all. All it does is give grens more options for scaling if they choose to pay for them. Same exact thing allies enjoy.

Funny, I offer the same thing to conscripts, but because I offer the same to grens you jump on the nope train because you can't fathom grens actually being complete shit, hopelessly outscaled from start to finish vs western front allies.

People might go conscripts if they actually had some late game scaling upgrades, WHICH THEY DONT.

Riddle me this katitof.
19 Aug 2016, 13:07 PM
#28
avatar of Katitof

Posts: 17914 | Subs: 8



but tommies and rifles have plenty of utility as well?

requires a crawler and you remembering that this ability even exists

so how do you deal with main line infantry then?




Well, rifles can't heal other squads, tommies don't have AT snare or even remotely useful nades :snfPeter:

And I suppose the same way it always happened-with sniper or more then 1 HMG.
19 Aug 2016, 14:33 PM
#30
avatar of Svanh

Posts: 181

Grenadiers have a few issues but they won't be solved by adding weapon upgrades.

Problems:

- Easily one-shot by explosives. Increasing squad spacing and/or making most (not Sturmtiger/B4/AVRE etc.) explosive weapons extremely unlikely to one-shot a squad (lower kill radius against infantry, increased damage radius to compensate) would improve the situation.

- Illogical reinforcement cost. Most widely-used squads have reinforcement costs at roughly 10% of squad cost or below. 5-man and 6-man squads are naturally in this range by virtue of the standard formula being half squadcost/(# models) but most four man squads have had their reinforcement costs adjusted to move them into this range (Obersoldaten, Panzergrenadiers, Infantry Sections, etc.). Grenadiers have not, so a Gren model actually costs more to reinforce than an IS model. Changing the reinforcement cost percentage to 40% would reduce their reinforcement cost from 30 to 24 (PG 34, IS 28, RM 28, Cons 20).

- Field First Aid is still one of the worst veterancy abilities. It takes two squads out of combat for 10-20 seconds to half-heal one of them for 20 munitions. Making it a full heal and reducing the cost to 0-10 munitions will improve the ability immensely. Even after improving this ability, replacing it on every squad except for Pioneers and Osttruppen should be considered.

- USF/UKF infantry scaling. Both Riflemen and Infantry Sections are reasonably balanced against Grenadiers and Panzergrenadiers so long as they do not have two BARs/Brens. I'd suggest increasing the slot size of LMG-type weapons (BAR, Bren, M1919A6, LMG42, LMG34) to 2 and adjusting the DPS of the affected weapons slightly if there are any issues. I'm aware that a fully-upgraded Infantry Section just manages to hit Obersoldaten levels but Obers are a continuing economic drain while weapon upgrades are not.

Here are some stats for Riflemen, Infantry Sections, Grenadiers, and Panzergrenadiers from another thread:

jump backJump back to quoted post19 Aug 2016, 13:50 PMSvanh
Let's look at some stats! :)

Durability:
SquadModelsTarget SizeVet 2 BonusVet 3 Bonus
Riflemen50.970.77x RA, 0.8x Cooldown0.8x RA, 1.3x Accuracy
Grenadiers40.911.4x Accuracy0.77x RA, 0.8x Cooldown
Panzergrenadiers40.80.71x RA, 0.75x Cooldown1.4x Accuracy
Infantry Sections4-50.80.76x RA1.2x Accuracy, 0.8x Cooldown, 2 SLEs


DPS:


















WeaponRange 5Range 10Range 15Range 20Range 25Range 30Range 35
M1 Garand5.844.333.402.802.341.971.67
BAR13.9710.457.996.976.035.174.37
Gren Kar98K5.074.373.823.373.002.592.26
Gren LMG426.977.568.108.578.999.269.20
Panzergren MP4415.3512.8110.107.695.463.381.44
Lee-Enfield4.594.263.973.713.483.172.89
Bren4.925.526.116.687.257.717.92
Scoped Lee-Enfield5.715.194.744.333.973.573.22


First and most obvious: the BAR and Bren are not superweapons. The BAR is roughly equivalent to a Panzergrenadier MP44 with slightly better long-range and slightly worse short-range capabilities. The Bren is strictly worse than the Grenadier LMG42, especially when you consider that the DPS stats for UKF weapons include the cover bonus.

We can see that vet-3, single-BAR Riflemen are easily killed by Panzergrenadiers at short ranges while having the advantage in a long-range fight. With two BARs, Riflemen are still worse than Panzergrenadiers at short range but have somewhat closed the gap and have a greater advantage at long range.

The Infantry Section-Grenadier contest goes much as one would expect. IS with a single Bren have roughly equal long-range DPS to Grenadiers when in cover and will win due to their superior durability. The Grenadier squad will still lose at short-range but will fare slightly better. Fully upgraded Infantry Sections are an Obersoldaten-level anti-infantry threat although Obersoldaten scale further with veterancy (2 Brens = ~LMG34, 2 SLEs + LE with vet = ~3 Ober KAR98Ks).

Hope this helps. :)
jump backJump back to quoted post19 Aug 2016, 14:05 PMSvanh

Easy enough, just multiply the target size by every RA bonus:

Riflemen: 0.59725 RA, ~669 effective health

Grenadiers: 0.7007 RA, ~457 effective health

Panzergrenadiers: 0.568 RA, ~563 effective health

Infantry Sections: 0.608 RA, ~526-658 effective health
19 Aug 2016, 14:37 PM
#31
avatar of Vuther
Senior Moderator Badge

Posts: 3103 | Subs: 1

jump backJump back to quoted post19 Aug 2016, 14:33 PMSvanh
Grenadiers have a few issues but they won't be solved by adding weapon upgrades.

- Easily one-shot by explosives. Increasing squad spacing and/or making most (not Sturmtiger/B4/AVRE etc.) explosive weapons extremely unlikely to one-shot a squad (lower kill radius against infantry, increased damage radius to compensate) would improve the situation.

YES

FUCKING PLEASE
19 Aug 2016, 23:22 PM
#32
avatar of ZombiFrancis

Posts: 2742

Remember that the 240mp squad has to/should retreat after 160 damage instead of the 240 damage of 280mp riflemen or 320 of 240mp conscripts.

Squad size has a great deal to do with field presence too. Grens have to be at full strength to recrew a team weapon without sacrificing the squad.

There's more than just, uh, wipeability at work with a squad size of 4.
20 Aug 2016, 03:35 AM
#33
avatar of RealName

Posts: 276

jump backJump back to quoted post19 Aug 2016, 13:07 PMKatitof
rifles can't heal other squads


rofl

Vet 1 medkit ability?

this is when I know you're running out of arguments.

also, the ability to scale better late game through better veterancy, ability to get two weapon ups, AND 5 man >>>>> "cost effective" mg42 and "much utilitez" rifle nade and snare.
20 Aug 2016, 04:25 AM
#34
avatar of thedarkarmadillo

Posts: 5279

im on the side of adjustment for grens
BUT
grens can also build bunkers allowing them to lock down areas as well as create staging points if resources allow
thats another tally on gren utility that is lacking on the tommy/rifle matchup

sigle arming rifles would be a way to fix multiple problems actually (make BARs a bit better to compensate of course) and help differentiate them from rangers and paras as well as diversify builds with more RE sprinkled in (assuming they maintain double equip)

i think its an idea worth exploring
20 Aug 2016, 19:33 PM
#35
avatar of ZombiFrancis

Posts: 2742

People realize that RA does not apply to explosive, fire, or ballistic damage right? Small arms v small arms fire only is neither common nor competitive in coh2. You can't just pretend it gives infantry mote effective health and still be accurate or meaningful.
23 Aug 2016, 02:38 AM
#36
avatar of iceman

Posts: 148

They should change it so you can only pick up 1 LMG from weapon racks and tweak the performance of those LMG to make it fair.



Relic used to have it you can upgrade to LMG and G43 rifles and have them both at same time.
23 Aug 2016, 04:48 AM
#37
avatar of __deleted__

Posts: 1225

People realize that RA does not apply to explosive, fire, or ballistic damage right? Small arms v small arms fire only is neither common nor competitive in coh2. You can't just pretend it gives infantry mote effective health and still be accurate or meaningful.

Ye, its just that the prevalence of AOE weapons, especially in the lategame, relatively impacts Grens more severely than numerically stronger squads, on top of their limited resilience to small arms. Which is also why it is relatively more diffifcult to keep them alive than the mainline infantry of the other factions, and which by extension is also the main factor why Grens rarely trade. However, "traditionally", (ie. before Brits/vet3 Rifle buff), Grens would eventually scale, at least in longrange engagements, which they no longer do. Upgraded sections dominate them at long range, and BAR rifles just tend to run up and push them off the field, which in the lategame tends to be also easier owing to yellow cover everyhwere...
23 Aug 2016, 08:50 AM
#38
avatar of ofield

Posts: 420

I second this. Allow grenadiers to be able to upgrade both if they are going to continue being the weakest mainline inf in the game


Grenadiers are not meant to carry Ostheer on their own, they are supposed to be part of a combined arms strategy.
23 Aug 2016, 09:18 AM
#39
avatar of Dangerous-Cloth

Posts: 2066

jump backJump back to quoted post23 Aug 2016, 08:50 AMofield


Grenadiers are not meant to carry Ostheer on their own, they are supposed to be part of a combined arms strategy.


Riflemen and Infantry sections are supposed to work in the same way are they not? Why can vet 3 riflemen roam the field with impunity whilst grenadiers and conscripts get raped by anything that does damage?
23 Aug 2016, 09:29 AM
#40
avatar of Ful4n0

Posts: 345



Riflemen and Infantry sections are supposed to work in the same way are they not? Why can vet 3 riflemen roam the field with impunity whilst grenadiers and conscripts get raped by anything that does damage?


why OST has t0 mg-42 and USF has to tech to get mg???

why USF tanks are paper tanks???

why OKW and BRITS are the only faction having non-doc heavy???

why USF rifles has to tech to get nades and have to be vet 1 to have snare???

why RE have shit fighting capabilities while spios are fucking gold when flanking enemy squads???

why RE and spios have to choose a commnader to get flames while SU and OST have them by default, even without side tech??



you have to look at the whole picture....

1 user is browsing this thread: 1 guest

Ladders Top 10

  • #
    Steam Alias
    W
    L
    %
    Streak
Data provided by Relic Relic Entertainment

Replay highlight

VS
  • U.S. Forces flag cblanco ★
  • The British Forces flag 보드카 중대
  • Oberkommando West flag VonManteuffel
  • Ostheer flag Heartless Jäger
uploaded by XXxxHeartlessxxXX

Board Info

832 users are online: 832 guests
0 post in the last 24h
8 posts in the last week
38 posts in the last month
Registered members: 49084
Welcome our newest member, sunwingamescom1
Most online: 2043 users on 29 Oct 2023, 01:04 AM