Some threads (especially replay threads) might seem incoherent or overly moderated simply because sometimes the users themselves have poor english or are just idiots speaking nonsense.
I have to agree though that some of the staff not involved with the community make some questionable decisions regarding moderation. Some players might jokingly call eachother a hacker/whatever within their own clan forum, and in swoops a global; both get warns and the clan forum gets a step closer to deletion for public cheating accusations. I won't go into detail, but this obviously won't be an issue on CoH2.org.
Also:
What did the gestapo to do people with opinions they didnt like? Exactly what those mods did.
You seem not know what the word 'exactly' means