Hi!  |
Basilone next time I won't allow you to make such an article for COH2.ORG >_>
I'll make one next time  |
funny thing is, you started changing topic of conversation, first i said that Soviet were lacking with good generals after Great Purge, and i don't know why dafuq you said that Gieorgij Zhukov was terrible (conclusion from my post or what?). When i said that a General was a priority in army commanding you started some shit talk about generals checking permimeter or scouting, sending scouts
dude srsly, l2read
Dude you came up in an argument about whether Russians were able to secure a perimeter or not with your history lesson about Russian generals. I never denied they were lacking generals and that they are important because it's not the point of the discussion. I didn't expect you to miss the point from the very beginning, I'm sorry. |
FFS twister you idiot... i'm talking about command hierarchy! i don't care about ranks, General>officer in this way, General is the head of planning actions, officer executes it
Deal with it
I think we're not talking about the same thing, or you didn't actually understand my last post and I can't help that. Either way it's not constructive, and I can't argue with you without you getting mad and throwing insults around, so I'm out. |
omfg, you really don't understand what i'm trying to say... Generals are responsible for everything what their officers (or w/e they are called) do on the front. General duty is to plan defence/offence, officers are executing it. you even know how command hierarchy works or not? because your post is senseless right now.
Now you're telling me that generals plan how each of their squad, platoon, battalion etc. will secure their perimeter every time they have to, right? If so I corrected my previous post to make it clearer:
So you seriously think that generals tell each of their platoon, battalion or division how to secure the perimeter every time they stop? Generals command armies, not single divisions. There's a hierarchy of command that makes that "routine" tasks such as securing the perimeter are planned, executed and supervised by other people, depending on the size of the unit. Officers are officers because they are able to make decisions and command smaller units on their own, without a general telling them what to do all the time.
"2. The officer must perform as the decision maker. This includes all matters that relate to their area of obligation. [...] The decision-making role is characterized by the officer’s duty to plan and organize. [...] Given a task, the officer must decide on a plan of action."
Source: US. Marine Corps. JROTC
If not, I'm afraid that your posts make less sense than mine. |
so it was do-what-you-want? or commanders gave the orders to scout or sth? srsly, now you are talking like crap shit, and i'm not trolling in this thread so STFU with your useless opinions about it
So you seriously think that generals go to the field and order each of their platoon, battalion or division to secure the perimeter every time they stop, and then check if it is well done? Generals command armies, not single divisions. There's a hierarchy of command that makes that "routine" tasks such as securing the perimeter are supervised by other people, depending on the size of the unit. |
|
4435 |
|
Barton: I'm glad you're good at history, but the point still stands that generals aren't responsible for scouting, something that Russians were actually pretty good at. Oh and just don't troll if you're not ready to hear what people have to say about it.
Chillty, you're right. I don't think I can handle the kind of education you got and your fine arguments; I'll stop wasting my time now. |
|
Barton, if I want history lessons I'll ask someone else than a failed troll spending his time miserably trying to get any form of attention on an internet forum. If you were as educated as you pretend to be, you would know that generals aren't responsible for securing a perimeter. Oh and the dark guy on every other COH2 poster is someone suspiciously looking like Gueorgui Joukov; I don't think it's because he was terrible at commanding, but you don't seem to know him anyway.
Chillty, I've heard that "Come at me bro" thing from people thousands of kms away many times already, so unless you're willing to travel you better shut up and and respect the badge that you've been given. |
Knew someone would argue with the Russian part. MVGame
GeneralHell: Not going to bother discussing anymore, so yeah let's stick to the topic MVGame
Knew you weren't educated enough to back that up with something more than a smiley. And there's nothing to argue with tbh, everyone knows already that you just have to be dumb to put that kind of remark in what you want to be a proper argument. |
0
9 
France
Belarus
Lt.Baumy
Relic Entertainment
cblanco ★ 
보드카 중대 
VonManteuffel 
Heartless Jäger 
