Blizzards don't add strategic depth
Posts: 2425
Permanently BannedOne side sees death by freezing as a hard limitation that restricts strategy negatively.
One side sees death by freezing as a hard limitation that restricts strategy positively.
On my own behalf, perhaps because I live in Finland, understand the dangers of cold intimately, and served through two winters in themilitary, and because of my predeliction towards the historical Finnish/Soviet engagements in winter, I may be biased.
On my perspective of the opposing view, I suspect it is related to the predeliction of vCoH vets to want the game to remain as vanilla as possible, also through the new Blizzard minigame phase.
Judging from what I have read, a more mutually constructive direction for discussion might be to talk about the currently existing timers before model loss and the timers and quantity of combat modifiers from cold.
This presents an opportunity for compromise for example in practical terms of increasing the timer before model deaths, and adjusting the values of combat modifiers from cold, without removing death, but still increasing the scope for decision making regarding infantry during blizzards, as is the main concern of one side, and the necessity for the hard limitation of death on the other.
Can we agree on this?
Posts: 1620 | Subs: 2
Bumping up the "how long would it take to freeze to death" timer would make dying from cold even more pointless and make it even less of a strategic decision, which is impressive because it barely is one right now.
Posts: 391
Incidentally - has anyone used attack ground with a flame unit to set fire to trees or similar and *then* get them next to it? Seems as though it would be a faster, albeit more temporary, solution to building a fire.
...and completely OT, I've noticed flamer packs being dropped in the latest version. Is this a change?
Posts: 642
I haven't had much success using flamers to heat stuff up, honestly.
Posts: 960
Blizzards are almost completely useless at this point, and are a detriment to gameplay. They hit every ~6.5 minutes, and basically KILL the momentum of a game.
Are you on a roll, taking over a map? Too bad. Blizzard puts that on hold for about 2 minutes, giving the enemy team time to recoup. Even if you don't camp beside a fire and keep moving, the move speed penalty is more than enough.
Right now, all blizzards do is add in a mandatory 'recoup' time. TBH the blizzards are the one reason that snow maps are actually FAR worse than Summer maps.
Posts: 2425
Permanently Bannedcold is not dangerous
And yet you want to remove the one thing that makes it dangerous at all.
Posts: 642
Posts: 783 | Subs: 3
I have to agree with you, Basilone.
Blizzards are almost completely useless at this point, and are a detriment to gameplay. They hit every ~6.5 minutes, and basically KILL the momentum of a game.
Are you on a roll, taking over a map? Too bad. Blizzard puts that on hold for about 2 minutes, giving the enemy team time to recoup. Even if you don't camp beside a fire and keep moving, the move speed penalty is more than enough.
Right now, all blizzards do is add in a mandatory 'recoup' time. TBH the blizzards are the one reason that snow maps are actually FAR worse than Summer maps.
I thought they removed the move speed penalty.
Posts: 1820 | Subs: 2
Anyway, if you state that the blizzard puts your army on hold for 2 minutes, then that's your problem. I dont have any problem moving my units during blizzards, its harder to see the enemy, but that doesnt mean i can't make a good sneak attack from all flanks, all because he wont see me coming untill im pretty close. And now that you can build fireplaces even turing blizzard, its not a big gamechanging factor anymore. You loose a game because of blizzard? learn to play!
Ofc im pretty sure its more to do with a person getting frustrated ("omfg.. blizzard again?! .. i can't be arsed") over the blizzard because how they are and not giving it a chance to perhaps learn to enjoy it. Some people can be really stubborn because ("OMG THEY DIDNT DO THINGS MY WAY!") how they think things should be. Give the cool mechanism a chance, i did and i don't get negative emotion because another blizzard hits. I find it really neat, because it looks cool with maxed out graphics and it gives the real feeling of the winter back then.
"From the mappers side of things"
I hope relic will include maps that dont have blizzard at all, as there were days that the sun shined bright and the weather was clear. If you can make winter maps without the blizzard then you already have 2 options how to make a winter map, so you can become really creative because you actually have the chance to control how the weather behaves in your map.
Posts: 642
In an ideal world, Blizzards should affect and compliment the map's design.
Posts: 960
I thought they removed the move speed penalty.
They might have lowered it since Alpha, but it's there.
Posts: 2425
Permanently BannedIn an ideal world, Blizzards should affect and compliment the map's design.
Very cool (pun intended) suggestion. Perhaps also a "Forecast XX% chance of Blizzards" in the map description on the match loading screen.
Posts: 1
Posts: 2779
Posts: 2561
Posts: 1585 | Subs: 1
I think it would be interesting to have a map that has a persistent blizzard that never goes away from the start.
Why would you want this? That sounds like a terrible idea imo.
Although I agree this definitely shifts towards necro posting, and is not immediately related to the discussion about strategic depth in blizzards.
Posts: 978
Blizzards are a pain for every game. CoH is a fast paced game where you need to capture points and apply pressure to outcap your opponent. Every feature that interrupts this, contradicts the thought behind CoH and good gameplay imo.
Thus, I have all Blizzard-maps vetoed. A map with continuous snowstorms would be the first one I´d lock.
Livestreams
14 | |||||
10 | |||||
1 |
Ladders Top 10
-
#Steam AliasWL%Streak
- 1.655231.739+15
- 2.842223.791+5
- 3.940410.696+6
- 4.35459.857-1
- 5.599234.719+7
- 6.278108.720+29
- 7.307114.729+3
- 8.645.928+5
- 9.10629.785+7
- 10.527.881+18
Replay highlight
- cblanco ★
- 보드카 중대
- VonManteuffel
- Heartless Jäger
Board Info
10 posts in the last week
28 posts in the last month
Welcome our newest member, vin88digita
Most online: 2043 users on 29 Oct 2023, 01:04 AM