Commanders
Posts: 2487 | Subs: 21
If you have no idea about some of the commanders or just can't seem to recall which commander does what then check out this updated tool to find out: http://commanders.rogerholmgren.com/
Also if you want to list which items in the current doctrines you think are the most useless/never used please feel free to do so.
Here is my list:
-On a more personal note I hope Relic sees this and realizes how flawed this commander system is.....
-I also support more variety please in doctrines, having the same ability in 9 Commanders is.....well......boring to say the least.
Posts: 309
Posts: 627
Posts: 308
Posts: 1838 | Subs: 17
Posts: 627
The fact that they have been sold as DLC means that they will never be fixed in a meaningful way, though, only "balanced" around its flaws.
If I were to fix it all without fucking over people who bought DLC, I'd make the three commanders you pick behave as a tree you put points into as opposed to a single linear progression of one of the three commanders.
Posts: 2561
NKVD Rifle Disruption is massively under rated imo. I use it the most out of all the Commanders(That I own). I reckon if I had Advanced Warfare or Partisan Tactics I might think differently.How do you possibly make use of it. It is 4 muni based call ins. You can't possibly use them all and it's probably better to use one that has maybe two strikes and other things you can make use of at the same time.
Decription is good, but it's not good enough to warrant atleast 2 unused abilities.
Posts: 627
How do you possibly make use of it. It is 4 muni based call ins. You can't possibly use them all and it's probably better to use one that has maybe two strikes and other things you can make use of at the same time.
Decription is good, but it's not good enough to warrant atleast 2 unused abilities.
Decryption is more than just "good", it is amazing and arguably one of the best Commander abilities in the game.
There is a drastic difference in how you play as Soviets knowing in advance what it is your opponent is doing, how far a long he is in tech - is he going to rush out that Gren or open with a 2nd Pio?
Oh, he's building a mortar squad instead of a HMG?
Oh, he hasn't built any units in a while, he must be saving for something.
I've had cases where I'm going my traditional opening and suddenly I realize he's after building two mortars in a row and only has a pio and grenadier on the field, and then I know I should build an extra one or two conscripts so I can take advantage of his poor map presence.
Or if he has 2 HMGs on a map full of buildings I know now to invest heavily in the early game.
I can easily say Decryption is one of the best, if not THE best, Commander ability in the game, based purely on the virtues of it coming from the first second of the game. You know everything your opponent is planning and it removes literally all shock value from his units. He's got that Flamer Halftrack? Well I'm ready for it. Got a PzIV out and I'm behind in tech? Well at least I know it's out there and I can start positioning and acting with knowledge of its existence.
Yeah, Rapid Conscription is inefficient, but it's usable. Recon Plane is always good to have. Propaganda Artillery is quite useful in the current meta, I think, due to the prevailence of infantry spam from Germans, and it's not like Soviets are Muni starved. Sturmovik does suck, though.
Posts: 20
You wouldn't.
Posts: 627
If you want radio intercept, why would you ever pick NKVD over Advanced Warfare, Armored Assault, or even Partisans?
You wouldn't.
Not everyone buys the DLC commanders. I work with what I use and have experience with.
I'm just saying, it's far more usable than people give it credit for.
Posts: 2561
Well it was free but I guess you didn't get it when it was. In that case I suppose you should use it, but advanced warfare is simply better if you ask me.
Not everyone buys the DLC commanders. I work with what I use and have experience with.
I'm just saying, it's far more usable than people give it credit for.
Posts: 598
Posts: 344
Germans most chosen: Mechanized Support Doctrine (well rounded, and the spotting scope is gusta.)
Soviets most useless: Conscript Support Tactics (Do I even need to elaborate?)
Germans most useless: Ostssssssssssssoppen Doctrine (Because Ostssuppen cannot in fact learn, shoot, perform, or not-die anything like a German.)
Posts: 1734
Permanently Bannedtry hull down panther, and try to kill it with any tank... It works best against CaptainRagequit and others who spam IS2. ( but it should be immune for at nades thou)
Relief infatry is the best choose against sniper spam.
if enemy doesnot have mortal, or any arty then the pak43 super good, but i admit one arty can kill it but it isnot for useing at front of the frontline.
Riegel mine actually better than teller because its makes the tanks immobilize, but i wouldnot used it against t70 spam.
Posts: 67
Anti inf mines and dshk is on 1 commander that sucks on lategame. Thats why its very rare.
Posts: 410
something like:
Guard motor company (Guards/Mark/Repair/T34/85)
Posts: 1702
On maps like stalingrad i go all out and upgrade all my cons with ppsh
Posts: 432
Here is my list:
Soviets:
Fear Propaganda Artillery - too slow to activate, too expensive.
Rapid Conscription - agreed.
M42 45MM At-Gun - disagree. They are so cheap and come out pretty early, and look about the same to players as an AT gun. They vet super quick, and vetted they used (as of a couple patches back) to be equivalent to ZiS guns. Unfortunately low health with tendency to get 1-shotted by Tigers.
Tank Traps - Would be a great ability if not stuck with the awful commander with no lategame.
PMD-6 Anti-Personel Mines - Super spammable and kills 1 man at least, but stuck with an awful commander.
DhSk - What the MG42 should have been. Great MG, stuck with awful commander.
Armored Vehicle Detection - Underused and not very useful with sound through FoW.
Forward HQ - Highly annoying on maps like Semois. Use in 2v2s to skip base healing. Lots of dice rolling with mortar crits.
Booby Trap - Effective, but not obvious enough. CoH1 had that clicking sound. CoH2 people start catching on fire randomly.
Hit the Dirt - Only bad because this patch made Cons bad.
-On a more personal note I hope Relic sees this and realizes how flawed this commander system is.....
-I also support more variety please in doctrines, having the same ability in 9 Commanders is.....well......boring to say the least.
Well, on the commanders, I hope this could still become a thing:
Imagine how dumb it'd be if the American inf doc was split into 4 different commanders:
MANS COMMANDER: Rapid Reinforcements - FHQ - Infantry Camo - Rangers - Infantry Attrition
ARTY COMMANDER: Field operations - Tank Traps - Offmap Artillery - Howitzer
SPAM COMMANDER: Tank Traps - Heroic Charge - Offmap Artillery - Infantry Attrition - OMCG
ELITE MANS COMMANDER: Field Operations - Heroic Charge - Rangers - FHQ - OMCG
Posts: 177
Posts: 578
Livestreams
60 | |||||
11 | |||||
6 | |||||
4 | |||||
1 | |||||
141 | |||||
25 | |||||
21 | |||||
8 | |||||
5 |
Ladders Top 10
-
#Steam AliasWL%Streak
- 1.831222.789+37
- 2.600215.736+15
- 3.34957.860+14
- 4.1107614.643+8
- 5.305114.728+1
- 6.916405.693-2
- 7.273108.717+24
- 8.722440.621+4
- 9.1041674.607-2
- 10.17146.788+1
Replay highlight
- cblanco ★
- 보드카 중대
- VonManteuffel
- Heartless Jäger
Board Info
8 posts in the last week
34 posts in the last month
Welcome our newest member, Falac851
Most online: 2043 users on 29 Oct 2023, 01:04 AM