Profile of skemshead

You don't actually play this game.. Do you?

Sure I do although no longer seriously.

You have a high rank, you obviously learnt how to deal with the stug e. Unless your a spammer then I can see why you dislike this unit.

The unit is strong, no doubt but it is really only op vs blobbers and spammers.

But if I am wrong you should explain why and not just post pissy little statements.

Storm troopers are the same. It is the consequence you pay for activating the ability, a bit like SU-85 activating los ability.

Otherwise the ability can just be activated everytime munis are available

The problem with this idea is it would further weaken Ost to the point of being unplayable. Ost are hugely susceptible to squadwipes as it is. Given that ost early game is hanging by a thread any further strengthening of Usf would be a disaster.

This is how game would play out. Usf pushes Ost of map or denies ost to 2 - 3 sectors. Usf spams 30 muni mines every where like soviets. Ost is then forced into buying 2 sweepers plus has to keep all troops together which favours usf. 222 would also be more restricted than it already is since 30 muni mine would kill it.

I can see the logic in this suggestion as it was a key feature to Coh1 Usf that worked well and was balanced but in Coh2 it would be a disaster.

Considering this doctrine only relies on infantry because of all the fuel getting coverted into munitions, it won't have any armor out unless the game lasts till the late game.
This gives you a lot of breathing space and you will only need to invest into AI.
Like, when I use it I often see these noobs build AT for no reason. And when I play against it I just spam AI, and if played right (meaning avoiding getting blobs caught by strafe runs), you will win because he will have to invest into AT, and you don't. Self-propelled howitzers and armored vechiles like the M8A1 Howitzer is very good counters to this doctrine, all you need to do is to make sure to avoid any AT strafes, which is easy. Whenever you see the recon plane, just move them.

Doctrine doesn't need nerf. You need the right units

100% Correct!!!!

This doctrine relies heavily on Usf player misreading the flow of the game. This of course can be hard to do if Ost holds off until midgame to reveal his hand.

However, as previously pointed out it does come with serious downsides and is entirely map dependant. It is very susceptible to large amounts of indirect fire due to grens suck vs this style of play. The easiest way to beat this is to plan for one big push since CAS strength is denying blobbers and tanks poorly microed. CAS cannot stop a big multi direction attack. 6 or 7 rifle squads with BAR flanking in combination with some type of off map arty will take out his at gun wall then followed up by sherman rush or m10 with the cheese crush will end the game for Ost.

It is a commander that punishes opponents that can't adapt and play the same style every game and then whine something is Op.

I don't use this commander often as it is an all strat. It can succeed and it can fall spectacularly. It also excludes teching and tank play which I kind of like in my play style but it can be something different once in a while as well as being immensely satisfying against someone who is hell bent on blobbing.

Disclaimer : My views are from a 1v1 perspective. I also admit this commander is cheese flavoured but no more so than many other abilities in the game.

#Company of Cheese.

Well you guys need to stop crying "Why no one is playing as allies". .

Just play the game and have fun. And if it's not fun for you, uninstall and enjoy life instead. Starting a new thread everyday won't change anything that much.

I see it as a form of therapy. Also if relic doesn't see any negative feedback it simply reinforces what they are doing.

As to the game not being fun, well it was fun until relic went full retard on Western Fronts and just turned the game in a giant clusterf*** which is seemingly predominately populated by scrubs just having a bash....