Much buffs needed, jacksons so stronk, T4 such impossible.
MG42 so underpowered at suppressing blobs.
And other popular claims being myth busted.
Also, thats what happens to micro if you play with cold fingers
What can I say about this very "interesting" replay?
Well, let's start with your "myth busting".
Jacksons were lost due to awful pathing, and neither of the USF players supported them very well. Later, they faced multiple panthers with no numerical nor range superiority.
Your T4 was completed at 18 minutes, with the first panther arriving at 22:47 minutes. Had there been sov players involved, you would not have the luxury of even surviving for so long due to call-ins coming earlier then your panther (85;s generally hitting the 15 minute mark, IS-2 slight later at 19-20 minutes).. Of course, you were lucky enough to get Semois in the first place - had it been any other map in the game without fuel conveniently placed next to your base, this would be pretty much impossible.
And now, for the piece de resistance, the HMG42 vs blobs.
For starters, it died 4 times, twice to blobs running up to it, and twice more due to nades+follow up rifle attack. The performance of the mg42 only improved somewhere in the second half of the game, when you smartly put s-mines next to it, and all the green cover was destroyed in the centre, leaving blobs to charge directly at it with no cover or even red cover.
But even then it wasn't that good, seeing as at one time, it failed to stop 3 squads from murdering a pak40, due to smoke usages from the ammies. (pak40 was also never picked-up by ammies for reasons i can't even begin to fathom).
So yea, the conclusion i can draw from this replay, is that a mg42 in cover with s-mine support can stop an incoming blob if it charges over no cover, uses no smoke and there is no flanking whatsoever.
Oh, and I almost forgot: the ranks of the players involved.
Both teams were randoms as a start.
bucho is ranked 3588 in randoms US
rgthat is rank 312 as random US
niceguy (OkW) is ranked 1400 in randoms
And you are ranked 1700 as ostheer random whilst your top rank in 1vs1 is 155 as ammies and 406 as ostheer 1vs1.
So I’d guess you might be playing just very slightly below your own rank.