Login

russian armor

Fury Movie! Tiger vs Sherman

PAGES (7)down
10 Dec 2014, 05:59 AM
#121
avatar of Ougeyal

Posts: 2



It was the terrain of the Bocage country that kept the Americans from breaking through in Normandy. Having a specialist heavy tank wouldn't have mattered when it would have just ran into the next series of hedgerows. Once the Americans hit open country where it could utilize its numerically superior armor and air power, it was a straight shot to the Rhine. Only thing stopping them from going further was that they outrun their supply.



A specialist heavy tank should have made it easier to make it to the next series of hedgerows instead of being knocked out of action like many Sherman were attacking pak 40s head om.
10 Dec 2014, 21:42 PM
#122
avatar of RMMLz

Posts: 1802 | Subs: 1



That's why I believe a Tiger commander wouldn't do such a mistake, plus the Fury seemed to have double a Kingtiger's armor in that movie!! lol too unrealistic anyways!

That's 1944 dude. Most of those guys were under-trained. Newbie tank crew, Newbie pilots, young soldiers etc etc.
But I wished there were some P4s and Stugs in the movie. E8 could easily kill them and that could make a good scene. The final scene was "American Heroes Kill All Da Enemies" kinda stuff. Those SS guys had Panzerfaust since the beginning why the hell did they fight till night and there officer was like "Ok now that we have lost 100 men let's finally use those fausts". Last scene was disappointing, but the movie was good in general.
12 Dec 2014, 20:24 PM
#123
avatar of Nathanm465

Posts: 204

Permanently Banned
jump backJump back to quoted post10 Dec 2014, 21:42 PMRMMLz

That's 1944 dude. Most of those guys were under-trained. Newbie tank crew, Newbie pilots, young soldiers etc etc.
But I wished there were some P4s and Stugs in the movie. E8 could easily kill them and that could make a good scene. The final scene was "American Heroes Kill All Da Enemies" kinda stuff. Those SS guys had Panzerfaust since the beginning why the hell did they fight till night and there officer was like "Ok now that we have lost 100 men let's finally use those fausts". Last scene was disappointing, but the movie was good in general.


I don't think the Germans would give a under trained tank crew a tiger, they would give those to more experienced crews. After the ardennes, yes then there were even fewer well trained German tank crews, but in Normandy, the remaining elite units got the tigers, not some under trained crew.

13 Dec 2014, 11:07 AM
#124
avatar of Burts

Posts: 1702

jump backJump back to quoted post2 Dec 2014, 22:53 PMkamk

That's a rather optimistic graph

http://books.google.de/books?id=lQoWAAAAQBAJ&lpg=PA12&ots=oV8IDsX0sr&dq=sherman%2076mm%20penetration%20vs%20tiger&pg=PA12#v=onepage&q=sherman%2076mm%20penetration%20vs%20tiger&f=false

http://books.google.de/books?id=SOTDzoncMroC&lpg=PA118&ots=xfJ31-27GH&dq=sherman%2076mm%20penetration%20tiger&pg=PA118#v=onepage&q=sherman%2076mm%20penetration%20tiger&f=false

... and so on.

Majority of all sources pretty much sum it up in a rather similar way: "get behind it, or don't even try".




Hmm, very interesting. Because the same author (Zaloga) says that the t-34/85 with APCR rounds was able to penetrate the panthers hull armor, which was MUCH thicker than the tigers armor, and considering that the t-34/85s gun was slightly worse than the 76mm M1 in terms of armor penetration, it is quite strange that it was not able to penetrate tigers reliably.


And the film is set in 1945, HVAP rounds were pretty rare,yes, but a tiger was also VERY rare in 1945.

I think this comes from the fact that tiger crews were always instructed to have their tanks facing the enemy tank at a 45 degree angle to maximize armor effectiveness. That is probaly where the 400m or even lower figure comes from. Not suprising, since a t-34/85 can penetrate a tiger I angled at 30 degrees from only 200-500 meters, while a non angled tiger it can penetrate at 1000m +.
13 Dec 2014, 11:31 AM
#125
avatar of Burts

Posts: 1702

13 Dec 2014, 12:18 PM
#126
avatar of CasTroy

Posts: 559


I don't think the Germans would give a under trained tank crew a tiger, they would give those to more experienced crews. After the ardennes, yes then there were even fewer well trained German tank crews, but in Normandy, the remaining elite units got the tigers, not some under trained crew.


Good point, makes sense.

Anyway it´s still a Hollywood movie, so we have to live with scenes which can be discussed due to realtiy. Me bothers the question, what the reallife participants from WWII would have said about this thread and all these argumantation of what was real and what was not.

Unfortunately I don´t know any former tiger crew member nor a sherman or T-34 crew member I could ask about the realsim of the final scene, as we discussed, and their own experiences.

The fact is that every participant must have been scared to death in combat no matter if you´re sitting in a trench or in a tin of steal called tank.
13 Dec 2014, 14:22 PM
#127
avatar of Cardboard Tank

Posts: 978

If you believe German veterans, the most significant weakness of Soviet tanks was that they couldn´t see and hit shit.
PAGES (7)down
1 user is browsing this thread: 1 guest

SHOUT IT OUT!

No ProfanityNumber of ShoutsRefresh Shout Box
Rosbone: This has been a paid for announcement from The People for the betterment of Coh Society.
Yesterday, 20:11 PM
Rosbone: And at a point when they need to have as many positives as they can. Instead they drop the ball and beg people for upvotes. You wouldnt need begging if you just did your jobs, like ever.
Yesterday, 20:08 PM
Rosbone: They put out new maps and increase the chance you get the new maps! Great idea! Thanks! Now its been 2 months of getting the same map over and over and over. How do they always fail themselves. Turn a positive into a negative everytime.
Yesterday, 20:07 PM
Rosbone: Seriously now, how is Relic still around. They cant do anything at all without F'ing it up.
Yesterday, 20:05 PM
GenMe: Its pointless even recording wins or losses in coh or any other RTS, they are being maphacked to death
Last Wednesday, 05:16 AM
aerafield: But make no mistake, this is not supposed to be a "DAK OP" rant. The whole game CoH3 is designed in a way so that stupid players can perform well and reach high ladder spots. Low effort, maximum reward strategies are everywhere
Last Tuesday, 22:51 PM
aerafield: Yeah I was gonna say, you clearly never saw the 10 IQ 10 APM blobbers roaming around on CoH3's top 20 ladders as DAK. Blobbing VSL Pgrens near the camouflage truck
Last Tuesday, 22:47 PM
Lady Xenarra: Nvm, I was wrong about VSL. Ultra efficient blob smashers go brrrrrr
Last Tuesday, 21:31 PM
Lady Xenarra: VSL is a myth, that is all.
17 Jan 2025, 20:10 PM
Rosbone: Ahhh I see the time span was less than a month for my view.
16 Jan 2025, 15:35 PM
Rosbone: 1600 is also lopsided based on 3v3 or 4v4.
16 Jan 2025, 15:32 PM
Rosbone: 4v4 has enough players or Wespe blobs but 3v3 doesnt? Some good axis teams are only playing 4v4?
16 Jan 2025, 15:31 PM
Rosbone: @aerafield What is up with the Coh3 win rates? 4v4 1500 has axis at 57% winrate. Same setting in 3v3 is allies at 52% win rate.
16 Jan 2025, 15:30 PM
Rosbone: Bueller? Bueller?
16 Jan 2025, 15:16 PM
aerafield: weekly shoutbox post :)
16 Jan 2025, 11:49 AM
Rosbone: :snfPeter:
09 Jan 2025, 11:04 AM
Willy Pete: So yes, he was very much doing Ullu things B-)
09 Jan 2025, 00:56 AM
Willy Pete: @Rosbone Couldn't spam pumas, he ragequit after 4 mins. Told his teammates they sucked and disappeared into a puff of smoke
09 Jan 2025, 00:55 AM
Rosbone: @Willy Pete Did he spam Pumas and do all the great Ullu things? :romeoHype:
09 Jan 2025, 00:16 AM
Willy Pete: I played against Ullumulu in coh2 today. The legend lives on
08 Jan 2025, 20:32 PM

Livestreams

Russian Federation 58
unknown 8

Ladders Top 10

  • #
    Steam Alias
    W
    L
    %
    Streak
Data provided by Relic Relic Entertainment

Replay highlight

VS
  • U.S. Forces flag cblanco ★
  • The British Forces flag 보드카 중대
  • Oberkommando West flag VonManteuffel
  • Ostheer flag Heartless Jäger
uploaded by XXxxHeartlessxxXX

Board Info

689 users are online: 689 guests
1 post in the last 24h
6 posts in the last week
57 posts in the last month
Registered members: 51000
Welcome our newest member, Steiedcrt44
Most online: 2043 users on 29 Oct 2023, 01:04 AM