You are way to diplomatic.
Uh Uh! Left to my own devices on Twitch stream, I am as capable of being timed out as anybody else, even for gentle ribbing
How could you ever analyse that amount of rage.
Well, if the poster plays straight and hoists up the replay, as ofc he should - and if it discloses obvious faults - you do not have to analyse the whole vid. Many effective replay commentaries I have read, often start with a detailed commentary,squad by squad, pointing out the deficiencies as they occur, then tail off after approx 6 minutes, with something like " You lost 2 Rifles by this stage and you were always going to be on the back foot etc etc "
And there is nothing wrong with that - if a novice is faring poorly, it will help him, and if the analysis is objective and not spiteful - then almost always, the poster who erred will thank the critic. Which is how it should be. Practical advice,administered dispassionately. That is partly why this board exists.
And this is a Mentor who sets a prime example
http://www.coh2.org/topic/5842/golradaer--northwestfresh-basilonereborn-modezarr-justbo
His style is different to what I have I described -but you can see a positive mentor shining through.
L2P is not abusive its the thruth.
Goldraeder did not need to use this phrase with his Mentees. If he had even thought about it, I am pretty certain he would have rejected the phrase as "crushing". 'L2P' is abusive,in the same way as "noob" is abusive. Good players, confident in themselves, do not need to be so disparaging