The Bickering Table

Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the Bickering Table. Here, our panel of Map-Making Judges will meet and discuss individual entries to the competition, give feedback and argue criteria for the purposes of whittling down the entrants to find the very best that the COH2.ORG community have to offer! There is also a strong chance of heavy drinking.

Our Commonwealth of judges include a mix of Mappers, whose expertise is the creation process; Strategists, who will critique the gameplay; and Artists, whose keen eyes will be focused on minor details, minimaps and loading screens.

At the Bickering Table we have:

MonolithicBacon

Maxi

Siberian

Zero

HelpingHans

Janne252

Von Kluge

Strummingbird

---

Here at the Bickering Table, our hand-selected Commonwealth will be discussing each map entrant and undoubtedly arguing over what's good and what's not. So, if you have any concerns, or you just want to hear what we are up to as the competition progresses, this is the place! Just don't post your maps here!


Like all good judges, we will be following our own set of rules, listed here.

Additionally, all other rules and more information on how to take part in the competition (or what you could be winning) can be found here.

And finally, if you want to know where to post your maps, you can find the thread here.


Keep your eyes peeled for updates and feedback on critiques maps, and eventually, the winning maps themselves!

The Bickering table is open, folks!

So, all you judges out there, can you please begin compiling a list of 9 maps each (3 1vs1 maps, 3 2vs2 maps, and 3 large maps) that you would like to see move onto the final of the competition.

Please keep this list to yourself, and we will discuss each map in turn with the votes from each judge when the deadline comes around.

"and we will discuss each map in turn with the votes from each judge when the deadline comes around", sorry if I missed anything, but when is that deadline?

Do we get any comments on the maps before that date? If a map requires any adjustments or something like that?
Thank you for the quick response

Yes, you should get feedback !

Alright, that's all I wanted to know! Thanks!

Cheers mate, thanks for participating !

Thanks for the opportunity!

Any time now

Is this contest dead or what? Is Relic adding any of these maps to the game??

Is this contest dead or what? Is Relic adding any of these maps to the game??

Maybe you have missed this announcement:
http://www.coh2.org/news/17229/map-making-contest-results

So the contest is over and winners have been decided. At least the winning maps are proposed to Relic.

Many thanks and congratulations to all of our winners! For those with First Place positions, I will personally be handing them over to the crew at Relic, in the hope that their keen eye will deem them worthy of being added to the Official Map Pool.