What is happening to this forum.
Scotts OP?
Pathfinders OP?
wtf is going on.
that s the effect of denying the playercard restriction as proposed 5 years ago
Posts: 2272 | Subs: 1
What is happening to this forum.
Scotts OP?
Pathfinders OP?
wtf is going on.
Posts: 772
Posts: 318
You know you can take OP seriously when they post multiple threads that are Nerf Allies/Buff Axis.
Posts: 1289
What was the win ratio of allies to axis in the 4v4 tourney? What was the win ratio of allies to axis in the last 1v1 tourney (particularly the final)?
Posts: 318
You do know that a small sample size of games with a select group of people indicates very little?
Its very possible that certain people within that select group synergyze better with certain factions, if that happens to be more with allies..
Posts: 919
So you think a bunch of completely randomized matches with all sorts of skill levels, the majority of which are far below what should be used as components to evaluate balance is a better way of determining balance issues, than a tournament of high skilled players effectively playing in controlled settings of multiple matches on the same map over and over and each team switching factions every match...?
Interesting logic.
Posts: 1890 | Subs: 1
What was the win ratio of allies to axis in the 4v4 tourney? What was the win ratio of allies to axis in the last 1v1 tourney (particularly the final)?
Posts: 1289
So you think a bunch of completely randomized matches with all sorts of skill levels, the majority of which are far below what should be used as components to evaluate balance is a better way of determining balance issues, than a tournament of high skilled players effectively playing in controlled settings of multiple matches on the same map over and over and each team switching factions every match...?
Interesting logic.
Posts: 1594
In your logic soviet t1 sniper opening with m3 and penals are op now because its been proven to be very effective by some high level players. Yet it costs quite a bit of mp and micro/combined arms and map control early on.
Posts: 1289
This is a Strawman, but if T1 with Sniper, Penal, and M3 play were a strategy that dominated at high levels then it would be arguably overpowered, yes.
Posts: 1594
I dont see how it is a straw man. If some strat dominates even among top players it isent neccesarely op. Or standard openings or builds are as wel.
Posts: 1158
Posts: 307
I would argue that when the strategy used by the top is able to be applied to all skill ranges and results in the same outcome, THEN it is overly strong.
6 | |||||
257 | |||||
10 | |||||
8 | |||||
5 | |||||
5 | |||||
4 | |||||
3 | |||||
2 | |||||
1 |