General Information
Register Time: 18 Nov 2012, 19:26 PM
Last Visit Time: 21 Oct 2024, 21:25 PM
Broadcast: https://www.twitch.tv/AECoH
Website: http://reddit.com/r/CompanyOfHeroes
Twitter: http://twitter.com/AECoH
Youtube: http://youtube.com/AECoH
Residence: United Kingdom
Nationality: United Kingdom
Timezone: Europe/London
Game Name: A_E
Quick question though, why allow Burmie back in when he too was dishonest and tried to trick you guys at first? Not doubting your choices or whatnot, but I find it interesting!
To be honest, because I asked him straight up whether he faked a draw with momo and he said yes. Then proceeded to explain why and it seemed to be from a difficulty organising due to time zones.
When I asked momo he explained about the 'dump file' issue, which based on all evidence seems to be untruthful.
If both had just told me about the time issues they would have been given a deadline extension or a replacement match.
It was a close call, and based on personal judgement, but I feel Burmie's honesty after the initial incident to means he should just be warned.
With all these people being denied participation in the tournament, is there any chance for late entry via replacing one of these players? I missed the initial sign up but if there are open spaces I would be willing to fill any of them and do any missed group matches or whatever.
Sorry Nosliw nice initiative! If you realised this last week during the placement games we could have done something, but not now sorry.
Due to a bug my zis gun it didn't work, we disagreed on wether i could've come back or not. So we had a third match incase refrees thought i would've lost it
OK agreed, zis gun bug game not counted, good sportsman ship by both players.
We are sad to announce that there have been four players denied entry due to uncompetitive behaviour i.e. not playing to full potential. This tournament will start on Saturday and ensuring all the players are of a fair and competitive mindset for one of the largest tournaments in our community's history is crucial.
Note to readers: apologies that we have to get this 'drama' out of the way, the good stuff is being worked on and all the hard seeding work is being done and seeds will be released by the end of the day
____________________________________________________________________ Official Declaration of denial of entry into Grand Championship Series
____________________________________________________________________
CaptainSPrice “Price” and -HOI- Sanka “lmctx”.
Based on all evidence given from multiple sources it appears that Price had a game against Lmctx that involved ‘boosting’ i.e. agreeing to lose to grant points from Price. A player whose position in the tournament was secured based on very strong rankings, to lmctx someone that’s position in the tournament was in doubt.
The replay was uploaded to COH2.ORG and the chat in the replay appears to line up with this logic. Several players alerted tournament admins to this and called the Price and lmctx out on it in chat. Lmctx admitted to it in chat and said they would replay game 1.
Price asked COH2.ORG admins to hide game 1 without alerting tournament admins.
Also based on past history of both players – Price attempting to troll in ‘King of the Hill’ game and faking an ESL final – Lmctx numerous counts of racist trolling and multiple bans from COH2.ORG. We think based on past reputation this official ruling should not be seen as in any doubt.
Screenshots of all evidence:
Note to these two players: there will be future tournaments, so we suggest both players take future competition more seriously, and we may be willing to give them another chance in the future.
Momo4oSho is not allowed entry to tournament on account of agreeing to report a 1-1 with Burmie when no games had been played.
Upon absolutely knowing that these games were not played due to Siphon X’s automated reporting for all custom game activity - the tourney organiser asked both players in IM whether they agreed to report a 1-1 in their games:
Momo denied it (was untruthful), Burmie owned up to it (was truthful).
This means Momo is now not allowed entry, but Burmie is allowed entry albeit with an official warning to read rules and compete properly in future.
Screenshots:
Note on Momo4oSho. Momo is a fantastic player, a great analyst, and a good community member. This ruling is made with deep regret, and it is urged in future utmost honesty is maintained at all times with regards to competitive activity.
Note on other players: PaulaD was allowed entry after deliberation but couldn't compete due to visa issues. Jove is in the Army for a year, and Noggano has end of university exams.
Also, added the other replays (all 110 that are available) for more commander choices.
Here are some map stats (couldn't add those to the original post as it got too long...)
Crossing in the Woods
ostheer
soviets
okw
usf
ukf
picked
10
10
16
10
6
won
8
3
10
4
1
won(%)
80
30
63
40
17
Crossroads
ostheer
soviets
okw
usf
ukf
picked
11
13
27
19
6
won
8
4
12
11
3
won(%)
73
31
44
58
50
Faymonville Approach
ostheer
soviets
okw
usf
ukf
picked
12
10
21
10
13
won
6
2
12
5
8
won(%)
50
20
57
50
62
Kholodny Ferma (Summer)
ostheer
soviets
okw
usf
ukf
picked
6
4
8
6
4
won
1
4
3
4
2
won(%)
17
100
38
67
50
That's it for the placement matches, thanks to the players and A_E!
More thorough analysis of the meta (much) later...
Fantastic Siphon X great work, I will now be compiling all results, applying modifiers for ELO and points accordingly, this will then work in combination with the captured automatch ranks to produce a tournament seeding. I will be releasing the provisional seeds today.
I however urge all players to ensure passports are sent in, this is a tournament that ends in a live venue final, being a paas port holder is vital. If you don't have one yet email me on redditcoh@gmail.com to say how you plan to get one and how long it will take.
I don't have a replay, cause we couldn't find time to play our second game, so we coin tossed and the RNG was with me YAY. I think its fair, we are equal skill level anyway.
Match result invalid we will now not count either game. Thanks for reporting and playing other matches. This effectivley means your match gave a draw. Which based on G1 is a fair result.
Don't know has (after a week) finally accepted my invite but now has not replied to a single message in over 3 hours (not counting the message i send him yesterday).
Im losing my patience with him.
It looks likely that people will be given a bye from the dontknow games based on his inactivity.
I use the API that the official leaderboards use to display the player game history. And true, that history does not list custom games. However, the API actually does send the data for custom games.
In fact, you will receive the last 10 games no matter what type of match that was (automatch or custom), but the webpage will only display the automatch games. The package contains a match_type_id, which is either 1, 2 3 or 4 for 1v1, 2v2, 3v3 and 4v4 respectively, or some other value (e.g. 0 or 22 or something) for custom games.
If you check e.g. Momo's history you see that it currently lists only 8 games, so 2 likely are custom games and not shown.
My script polls the history for all players in the GCS every 3 hours and then extracts the custom games between players that are in the same group. And the script this morning didn't show the Momo/Burmie games. Of course it is possible that they both did more than 10 games after they played their matches, in which case they would be lost...
Problem is, I'm currently on vacation and away from the machine that downloads the data. It mails the result to me every 3 hours so I can update the post, but I can't look into why the two games don't shown up in the list now...
Ok lets take this to PM, I need to know some specifics when you get back from holiday.