Profile of Felinewolfie

The Tiger is in a good spot. When well supported it can be devestating. It’s just not like what it use to be where it can essentially be a one man army.

I find too many players have the Rambo / MOBA syndrome.
Wanting for Axis Rambo Units that can do everything, never fail, have no weaknesses and
cannot be stopped and 1 shot everything.

- Remove AT Planes.
- Remove TD Tanks.

"I love scissors, I love how they rape paper. But removing rocks altogether would make scissors
a lot more balanced. Sigh. Scissors without a counter." (PS: 2 Maxims is spamming, 12x MG42 is not).

I explicitly mentioned that I am not including the ATG in the very first sentence. On my closing sentence I also reiterate that I am not including the atg, as well as adding that I am not including the stug to the discussion.

I doubt you actually read my post carefully before trying to rant, if you somehow missed my first and last sentence.

- No reason why ATG should be discriminated against as compared to Tank Destroyers.
Why should Tank Destroyers which are more expensive be LESS effective than ATGs?

All tanks which have long guns or AT capable should have a -99% accuracy penalty.
All ATG, AT mines, PzFaust, PzShrek, PIAT, Zooks, AT tank guns to receive a -99% accuracy penalty.

Why not the StuIIIG? It's a tank destroyer. Puma. -99% accuracy nerf and ROF nerf as well.
Pz4, Panther, Tiger, T34/76, T34/85, IS-2, ISU152, Elefants, JgTiger.

Only the Sherman 75, Pz2, Centaur, and Stuart and T70 (Puma to be hard nerfed) keep original hit values.

I think suppression and damage should be removed on all grenades, HMGs, mortars.

Isn't the topic to remove all and any counters from the game?
If you remove counter to German Heavy Armor, then either the game becomes an instant German I-win
button, or you open the door to massive heavy nerfs to German Armor.

- And ATG and StuIIIG would need to be hard nerfed as well.

Definite case of "I love scissors, but please remove rocks, as they ruin my scissors"

Ultimately, your proposal removes allied Destroyers from play, making Germans invincible.
And strong Axis bias if you believe Pak40s and Pak43 and StuIIIG should not be nerfed too.

"Allied Rocks annoy me. But it is important to keep axis rocks to squad Allied scissor spam"
We are no longer talking rock paper scissors, here (ie: Strategy).

It's more a case of "only axis should own guns"

"* Does your proposal include things like -50% chance to hit, say, from a tiger or Panther firing
at Shermans and T34s?

As the Panther is rather much of a Tank Destroyer, it should also receive such a nerf.
... Would would make it completely useless.
Remove suppression from HMGs, you make blobs unstoppable.

And so forth.

Just thought of something. If you hard nerf heavies by -99% accuracy, then they wouldn't be played.
Then TDs are also no longer necessary and can be hard-nerfed -99% accuracy (including ATGs and STUG)

The OP allied TDs exist because of OP German end-game armor. Remove both (and ATG and new balance).
SU76 and StuIIIG and Puma must also receive the same treatment.

(TD meaning the su-85, jp4, jackson, and the Firefly. I am not including the atg)

weapon accuracy against a target is calculated as the listed accuracy multiple by the target's size.

For example, the 75mm kwk 40 have a accuracy of .025-.05, while the t34/76 have an size of 22. Therefore the kwk 40 have an accuracy of .55 against the t34/76.

(in practice it is actually higher due to stray shot, but .55 is a decent baseline).

Heavy tanks (and more powerful units in general) have a higher size. The tiger for example have a size of 26 compared to the pz4's 22.

This is actually historical and realistic as thicker and heavier armor require more complex suspension, and more powerful gun are generally bigger. This in turn also demanded more powerful engine, which are generally bigger as well. The tiger was 3 meters high compared to the p4's height of 2.68m.

This means that heavy tanks like the tiger are easier to hit, but in theory make up for that fact by having higher HP and armor.

The issue with Tank destroyer right now is the fact their accuracy is too high.

assuming the target have a size of 22 (panzer4).

the jp4/FF 0.04 - 0.06 = 0.88 - 1.32
the Su-85 .04 - .055 = .88 - 1.21
the m36 .035-.05 = .77 - 1.1

this completely nullify the advantages of having a smaller target size. Even with the 50% accuracy penalty, a moving td still achieve an accuracy of 44% against medium tank.

TD doesn't need their current insane accuracy to counter heavy tank, as heavy tank are easier target to hit.

Assuming a target of 26 (tiger and king tiger).
panzer4 .025-.05 = .65 - 1.3
panther .03-.06 = .78 - 1.56

this means the extreme accuracy on the TD are complete overkill. Their accuracy could go down to .025-.05 and still be good against heavy. the Su-76 currently have an accuracy of .025-.05

(atg are different since they are support weapon. I've left out the stug since it's only got 50m range)

So, saying StuG and and Jpz4 and JgTig and Elefant should be hard nerfed.
As well as anything Anti-Tank gun, PAk38, Pak40, Pak43, 17 pdr, firefly.
Let's all give them -99% to hit.

Also make mortars incapable of hitting MGs and buildings.
And make ...

Basically remove any counter to anything.

"I love scissors, therefore, rocks should be banned".
That's what you are saying.

i vote to add I win button for Axis if survive for 20 minutes to simplify the topic.

On the SU85 and Jackson getting pen bonus instead of high ROF, it's because it was
overperforming vs Pz4. So now, it doesn't eat up Pz4 quite so fast. And it can pen
Super heavies more consistantly.

If you guys want to see Jackson and SU85 go back to their high dmg, low pen ways,
then you'll basically see why things were changed in the first place.

PS: Also, mass super heavies demonstrates that there's no balance in 4vs4

Triggered much Katitof? you must be a hardcore brit player. Also rank shaming is pathetic. Grow up please.
Churchill and Comet are heavy tanks just like the Tiger. Relic is so ally biased.

===============
- KV1 and Churchill are infantry tanks. Slow, with short guns. A STUGIII solos them easily.
- Tiger is faster with long high-pen gun.

The Comet is not a heavy tank. It is a Premium Medium.
... Just like the Panther. Which is not limited to 1.

As for being the most "OP" unit in-game...
Is Rock OP? Is Scissors OP? Is Paper OP? Which is the most OP to you?
I suspect whatever is most OP is that counter to that which you love.

It's all relative.
Churchills are a joke. They lost their good armor ages ago.
Even Croc Churchill got a serious nerf recently, why do you bitch now?

Why are you guys even still posting if the game is completely dead?