Feedback for Commander Revamppatch

Jump back to quoted post25 Sep 2018, 19:55 PMKirrik

Speaking of NKVD, I think that Scorched Earth trap is a gimmick.

Jump back to quoted post25 Sep 2018, 19:57 PMKatitof

You think so?
Imagine it on your cutoff then.

Jump back to quoted post25 Sep 2018, 19:55 PMKirrik

Speaking of NKVD, I think that Scorched Earth trap is a gimmick, there are far better munition sinks in that doctrine (IL-2 loiter, Propaganda).

Maybe it could be replaced with Partisans (PPSh version)
It feels kinda weird that NKVD doctrine has zero infiltration units, and if there are units in the game that desperately need a rework/buff thats them.

Jump back to quoted post25 Sep 2018, 20:02 PMKirrik

It can be disabled with mine detector, isnt it? It's hardly worth more than a normal mine
Plus trap itself is set up by engineers, you can give it Partisans too and rework them as well

Jump back to quoted post25 Sep 2018, 20:31 PMJibberJabberJobber

Saving your cut-off for 90 seconds is not worth it? And what about ruining your opponents cut-off? Your opponent pushed you back and wants to cap the fuel? Nope, he's stalled for 90 seconds while you can reinforce for a counterattack. It's a resource denial tool and an extra thing for Axis players to worry about. If that doesn't seem worth it to you for 35 munitions then don't use it.

Yeah, sweepers can counter it, but the enemy pios would have to be at the right place at the right time and not be placing mines / repairing vehicles / building at base / fighting.

Jump back to quoted post26 Sep 2018, 02:55 AMMakiesKurisu

Can simply add ez8 to mechanized instead of making 76 sherman more like a ez8? and leave rifle companys for later revamp?
in addition, reserve amour is better fit the theme of rifle company(maybe no 76 sherman but able to upgrade 75 sherman to crocodile. In fact, I don't think it make sense to upgrade a 75 sherman if u can build a 76). exchange their ability would be fine.

Jump back to quoted post25 Sep 2018, 20:37 PMKirrik

I doubt you can pull that off more than once after opponent realizes you got NKVD selected. And since trap is not an offmap it could be given to Partisans too, just within this doctrine like Recon Pathfinders who get special abilities compared to normal Pathfinders

Jump back to quoted post26 Sep 2018, 06:43 AMEsxile

You haven't play Coh1 to say that. Imo this ability is just something that shouldn't been design first hand as stupid it is and completely going against the game generic rules.

Jump back to quoted post26 Sep 2018, 06:43 AMEsxile

You haven't play Coh1 to say that. Imo this ability is just something that shouldn't been design first hand as stupid it is and completely going against the game generic rules.

Jump back to quoted post26 Sep 2018, 06:43 AMEsxile

You haven't play Coh1 to say that. Imo this ability is just something that shouldn't been design first hand as stupid it is and completely going against the game generic rules.

Jump back to quoted post26 Sep 2018, 10:42 AMOsinyagov

I want to ask some questions about 76mm Sherman:
1. Does veterancy three modiffer spread on HVAP shells?
2. Does veterancy three got changed for M4C too?
3. Why M4C didn‘t get HVAP like his twin brother from USF?

Jump back to quoted post26 Sep 2018, 11:18 AMVipper

There is absolutely no reason for the soviet and USF to have the stats and role. The USF is already superior with radio net, smoke and crew.
Veterancy issues have to do with the fact that soviet version uses the very high T-34/76 vet bonuses and the penetration buff seem out of place when the unit already has HVAP shells options.

It would be eqully out of place for the 75mm Sherman to get more AOE in its main gun.

Allows M4A3 76mm tanks to be deployed from the Battalion Command Post; same stats as the M4C, can use Smokescreen ability.

76mm Sherman
-Veterancy Three 0.8 reload modifier replaced with +25% main gun penetration.
-Can now swap between regular ammunition and HVAP; HVAP has improved penetration and accuracy, but increases reload time by 1.6 seconds.

1. Does veterancy three modiffer spread on HVAP shells?
2. Does veterancy three got changed for M4C too?
3. Why M4C didn‘t get HVAP like his twin brother from USF?

PANTHER CHANGES
Both Panthers are being standardized in reload and accuracy to improve performance; the health bonus at veterancy 2 has been shifted to the unit’s stock performance to improve its survivability against tank destroyers. Now possibly in its best spot yet.
• Wehr Panther fuel cost from 175 to 185
• Wehr far accuracy increased from 0.03 to 0.035
• HP increase from 800 to 960 (all variants)
• Front armour reduced to 260
• Veterancy 2 +160 HP bonus replaced by +10% armour bonus
• OKW Panther reload from 6.1 - 6.4 to 5.2 - 5.6
• Rear armour reduced from 110 to 90 (all variants)

Jump back to quoted post26 Sep 2018, 12:45 PMOsinyagov

....
So, my questions still valid.
....
P.S. During last rebalnce, Panthers get the same stats. So it is possible to balance one unit in two factions.
...

Jump back to quoted post26 Sep 2018, 20:54 PMAndy_RE

Stormtroopers
-Now spawn with Grenadier Kar98ks; can upgrade to MP40s for free. 15 second upgrade time in order to require more strategic deployment.

Jump back to quoted post26 Sep 2018, 21:18 PMStorm Elite

Just one question: can the upgrade be initialized while in a building?