Login

russian armor

The abysmal state of the KV1

2 Oct 2016, 12:44 PM
#21
avatar of bert69

Posts: 150

KV1 is not that bad to the point of being totally unusable, it is still a call-in tank which means you don't have to tech up to purchase a vehicle, which means you can get more kv1s out earlier and simultaneously. 80 fuel to tech up to t3 + 70 fuel for t70 = 150 fuel OR 1 KV-1 @ 8CP. Counter Attack tactics is a totally usable commander especially for heavy t2 openings that include more than 2 maxims because shock troops + maxim shut down any flanks while a well positioned zis gun can ward off any harassing light vehicles. Just because someone picked a commander that includes stuka dive bomb doesn't make yours useless, it just nullifies one heavily RNG dependent unit while you still have a more than capable shock troop call in, and 2 great utility abilities (For the Motherland and Recon Plane)
2 Oct 2016, 13:43 PM
#22
avatar of vietnamabc

Posts: 1063

The Churchill gets mainly offensive bonuses as well. More importantly the Churchill gains no defensive or health bonuses with its vet. It's ability to act as a meatshield is still quite solid.

Although I guess it does have that weird vet 3 engine self-repair thing.

But the whole pseudo-command tank aura would be such a massive change to the unit, not to mention the aura itself would have crazy impact on infantry combat. The impact on team games I won't even bother to get into either. I mean, the B-4 commander was already a pretty troll commander in team games to begin with.

A vet 1 hulldown wouldn't be too crazy though. But IMO vet 1 abilities need to set aside altogether. Crams the pacing of vet bonuses into only 2 steps.

Churchill works because its main gun is way better than the KV-1 peashooter and UK got super RE repair, if you got heavy engineer + 5-man squad than Churchill can be repaired in like less than 1 min to get full health, also lots of doctrine synergy very well with Churchill like Emergency Repair or running a Churchill under Artillery Cover/Strafing also works.
By contrast, Soviet CE takes ages to repair stuffs, KV-1 is not that threatening compared to Churchill (Does it get its MG buffed like T-34?).
2 Oct 2016, 16:18 PM
#23
avatar of Dangerous-Cloth

Posts: 2066



By contrast, Soviet CE takes ages to repair stuffs, KV-1 is not that threatening compared to Churchill (Does it get its MG buffed like T-34?).


I had my panzergrenadiers standing in front of three KV1s and 2 of them were firing their mgs at my men, they didn't really do much lol.
3 Oct 2016, 11:16 AM
#24
avatar of The amazing Chandler

Posts: 1355



You better start using it :P





Watched the replay, very nice use of the B4.
The last shot thou before it got destroyed (on the TA) saved your ass :D
3 Oct 2016, 11:25 AM
#25
avatar of Australian Magic

Posts: 4630 | Subs: 2



Watched the replay, very nice use of the B4.
The last shot thou before it got destroyed (on the TA) saved your ass :D


I know :sibHyena:

It's just I wasn't focused on the game on that day, I didn't check doctrines etc etc and I wasn't even thinking about TA :P

I had similar game last week. I saw M36 (somehow I thought it's M10) then I saw Pershing but I still thought that Pershin is supported by M10 not Jackson :luvDerp:
3 Oct 2016, 11:32 AM
#26
avatar of Mr.Smith

Posts: 2636 | Subs: 17

Needs some work and I believe it should very much be a meatshield tank. I'll plug my suggestions here:

-Veterancy 2 Horizontal Traverse Speed removed. Replaced by an aura that boosts nearby infantry, increasing accuracy by 10% while reducing received accuracy and cooldowns by 10%. 25 meter radius.
-Veterancy 3 Reload modifier removed.
-Veterancy 3 Speed and rotation modifier from 1.2 to 1.15.
-Veterancy 3 allows the KV-1 to repair 1.25 health every second when out of combat and increase the tank's health by 160.
-Health from 800 to 960
-Vet 1 to "Defense Mode" from "Capture Point". Defense mode halts all movement of the tank in exchange for 0.8 recieved damage and lowers reload speed by 0.85.

Now you have a very tanky vehicle. It doesn't kill much at all, but it's a very annoying meatshield to deal with. The aura might be too much, but it could be a timed ability. I don't think it would need limits as you would feed TDs XP, though Mother Russia could use some looking at. It's like Valiant Assault, but way better since you get an armour bonus.

Veterancy requirements might also need to be increased with these changes.


I don't like the idea of presenting utility in the form of passive always-on auras. If KV-1 had the ability to throw smoke around to cover an advance, that would be enough to convince me to build one.

Otherwise, the idea for the aura could work, but only if it isn't folded into a passive, always-on aura.

Auras, in general, can have unintended consequences. Especially if you combine these with new penals and the "For Mother Russia" buff that comes with the same commander.

Otherwise, the rest of the buffs seem to signal to me, that KV-1 is meant to be a tank that is extremely fussy to take down; which isn't a bad thing, in general.
nee
3 Oct 2016, 14:07 PM
#27
avatar of nee

Posts: 1216

I agree about auras, the results would be the unit being used mainly for its aura, and the aura potentially stacking with global effects. The lack of limits to the vehicle (also its lacklustre firepower as T4 unit call-in) means its usefulness is diminished if the auras don't stack.

If you REALLY insist on the aura idea, then make it a toggled one, like the tank commander pops out of his hatch, inducing some penalties as a tradeoff, and of course limiting it to 1 since it's turned into a de facto officer unit.

Another idea worth considering is copying the coh1 Panzer4 IST, which can toggle to immobilize but increase its firing rate and turret traverse speed. Unable to move but fires faster means it's a tanky anti-infantry vehicle.
3 Oct 2016, 15:58 PM
#28
avatar of Dangerous-Cloth

Posts: 2066

jump backJump back to quoted post3 Oct 2016, 14:07 PMnee


Another idea worth considering is copying the coh1 Panzer4 IST, which can toggle to immobilize but increase its firing rate and turret traverse speed. Unable to move but fires faster means it's a tanky anti-infantry vehicle.


This is a great idea. But wouldn't it sort of make the KV1 a underpowered KV2 in that aspect?
3 Oct 2016, 16:02 PM
#29
avatar of Vuther
Senior Moderator Badge

Posts: 3103 | Subs: 1



This is a great idea. But wouldn't it sort of make the KV1 a underpowered KV2 in that aspect?

More like a possibly actually good KV2 :luvDerp: KV1's probably a lot more usable than KV2, as not great as the KV1 is
5 Oct 2016, 13:53 PM
#30
avatar of vietnamabc

Posts: 1063



Watched the replay, very nice use of the B4.
The last shot thou before it got destroyed (on the TA) saved your ass :D

Man RNJesus surely loves him, I've never managed to make B4 work, always miss at important moments, also never managed to float 600mp as SU.
6 Oct 2016, 15:52 PM
#31
avatar of Trubbbel

Posts: 721

Both KV-1 and KV-2 need something.
1 user is browsing this thread: 1 guest

Livestreams

unknown 21
Germany 899
unknown 45
unknown 15

Ladders Top 10

  • #
    Steam Alias
    W
    L
    %
    Streak
Data provided by Relic Relic Entertainment

Replay highlight

VS
  • U.S. Forces flag cblanco ★
  • The British Forces flag 보드카 중대
  • Oberkommando West flag VonManteuffel
  • Ostheer flag Heartless Jäger
uploaded by XXxxHeartlessxxXX

Board Info

722 users are online: 722 guests
0 post in the last 24h
8 posts in the last week
37 posts in the last month
Registered members: 49093
Welcome our newest member, Transue
Most online: 2043 users on 29 Oct 2023, 01:04 AM