Commander Update Beta 2021 - British Feedback

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 08:45 AMKronosaur0s

I just saw tightrope video of UKF particularly Raid sections and Vickers K... is this a joke or what? Winning every single engagement regardless of vet and range, congrats! Engineers/vickers/and other type of infantry units no need to be used anymore!

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 08:45 AMKronosaur0s

I just saw tightrope video of UKF particularly Raid sections and Vickers K... is this a joke or what? Winning every single engagement regardless of vet and range, congrats! Engineers/vickers/and other type of infantry units no need to be used anymore!

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 09:00 AMKiwiBirb

Recovery sappers are a bit lame right now - not worth a commader slot just for the ability to throw smoke grenades and salvage.

maybe they could be given lee enfields and the ability to build bunkers and sandbags?

and then they could be added to advanced emplacements, so that advanced emplacements could build bunkers, and make advanced emplacements less one dimensional-emplacements only?.

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 09:03 AMVipper

Recovery sapper come with smoke grenades/salvage/increased repair speed. They are quite a useful unit.

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 09:13 AMKiwiBirb

uh i just dont think that the smoke nades and salvage is a full commader slot i guess.

they do start with better repair speed but i think -? that normal engineers can get that saim repair speed after minesweeper + bolster?

I just was hoping to make them more flavorful and unique i guess. i guess not

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 09:13 AMKiwiBirb

uh i just dont think that the smoke nades and salvage is a full commader slot i guess.

they do start with better repair speed but i think -? that normal engineers can get that saim repair speed after minesweeper + bolster?

I just was hoping to make them more flavorful and unique i guess. i guess not

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 08:45 AMKronosaur0s

I just saw tightrope video of UKF particularly Raid sections and Vickers K... is this a joke or what? Winning every single engagement regardless of vet and range, congrats! Engineers/vickers/and other type of infantry units no need to be used anymore!

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 09:58 AMVipper

Maybe not. I was simply point out that that they are not a bad unit.

I guess one could try the following:

"Field Recovery Operation" renamed to "Royal Sapper" move "Advanced Emplacement Regiment" replacing
"Defensive Operations".

Ability allow to build Royal sapper from HQ (CP 0 call-in should be avoided since it map depended)

Unit has savage, smoke grenades and come with 5 rifles. Repair speed replaced by 20% repair speed to emplacement plus no damage penalty when repairing.

This should solve repairing issue for the commander.

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 10:10 AMmadin2

u have to compare the raid section to other doctrinal infantry like jäger light from okw not to mainline

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 08:45 AMKronosaur0s

I just saw tightrope video of UKF particularly Raid sections and Vickers K... is this a joke or what? Winning every single engagement regardless of vet and range, congrats! Engineers/vickers/and other type of infantry units no need to be used anymore!

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 11:02 AMSander93

I still dream of the day people consider a preview an actual preview (i.e. a testing ground) and keep in mind that especially in the first iteration there are going to be a lot of values that need further tweaking. We're creating a new weapon here, is it really a surprise that the values might be off on the first try? Wait for further iterations before coming up with these kind of remarks please. This type of feedback is worthless.

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 09:58 AMVipper

Maybe not. I was simply point out that that they are not a bad unit.

I guess one could try the following:

"Field Recovery Operation" renamed to "Royal Sapper" move "Advanced Emplacement Regiment" replacing
"Defensive Operations".

Ability allow to build Royal sapper from HQ (CP 0 call-in should be avoided since it map depended)

Unit has savage, smoke grenades and come with 5 rifles. Repair speed replaced by 20% repair speed to emplacement plus no damage penalty when repairing.

This should solve repairing issue for the commander.

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 11:02 AMSander93

I still dream of the day people consider a preview an actual preview (i.e. a testing ground) and keep in mind that especially in the first iteration there are going to be a lot of values that need further tweaking. We're creating a new weapon here, is it really a surprise that the values might be off on the first try? Wait for further iterations before coming up with these kind of remarks please. This type of feedback is worthless.

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 11:02 AMSander93

I still dream of the day people consider a preview an actual preview (i.e. a testing ground) and keep in mind that especially in the first iteration there are going to be a lot of values that need further tweaking. We're creating a new weapon here, is it really a surprise that the values might be off on the first try? Wait for further iterations before coming up with these kind of remarks please. This type of feedback is worthless.

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 13:05 PMSupremeStefan

Unit name Raid section sounds ok but i think that unit should represent foreigners something like ostrupen.

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 13:28 PMSupport Sapper

Canandian or australian section sound like it. especially australian, if the loadout is 5-6 man squad with molo and cheap reinfoce cost, resemble conscript.

Jump back to quoted post4 Apr 2021, 13:31 PMVipper

Think voice lines is the main issue...