Commander Tiers
6 May 2015, 00:54 AM
#42
Posts: 1954
Soviet Shock Army in T4? Shocks, ppsh's, 120's, ML-20. - On maps like Steppes it might be tier 4 but on City 17, Lienne Forest, etc, it seems much better than that. The worst part about it is Relic's decision to give everyone CAS which makes it hard to use ML20.
6 May 2015, 18:53 PM
#43
Posts: 3552 | Subs: 2
Soviet Shock Army in T4? Shocks, ppsh's, 120's, ML-20. - On maps like Steppes it might be tier 4 but on City 17, Lienne Forest, etc, it seems much better than that. The worst part about it is Relic's decision to give everyone CAS which makes it hard to use ML20.
Well everything in Shock Army is so gardening expensive that if you are actually using everything in it you can't really afford very much of anything else and you'll have an army lacking AT and armour
Shocks, 120mm Mortar, ML-20 are all manpower heavy, and if you are getting Cons with PPSH they are going to bleed from getting into CQB
If you are on the right map and/or in a team that can cover the other bases then fine, but that makes it quite situational and it lacks any call in tank of it's own or anything that helps to fight Axis armour.
Resident Soviet Whiner and Grand Master Bias Jedi; General Secretary of the Soviet Whine Hydra Collective; Axis Hating Sheeple; Allied Butt Buddy! Collect Them All!
Also the African Branch of TAB Bulletins
PS: The Italian Army fought with courage and skill
Also the African Branch of TAB Bulletins
PS: The Italian Army fought with courage and skill
8 May 2015, 09:39 AM
#44
Posts: 6
More experienced players, might have a different list but that's why it's an overall tierlist.
I created the topic (http://www.coh2.org/topic/33573/commanders--an-overwhelming-amount-of-options) because I was looking for something like this.
And now here it is, you have my thanks!
This will be a great help for me to focus my learning of the different commanders.
And to be honest, debating the commander list and personal preferences in the comments will only help me more, so please do continue!
I created the topic (http://www.coh2.org/topic/33573/commanders--an-overwhelming-amount-of-options) because I was looking for something like this.
And now here it is, you have my thanks!
This will be a great help for me to focus my learning of the different commanders.
And to be honest, debating the commander list and personal preferences in the comments will only help me more, so please do continue!
8 May 2015, 21:45 PM
#45
Posts: 3552 | Subs: 2
Glad to be of service
Resident Soviet Whiner and Grand Master Bias Jedi; General Secretary of the Soviet Whine Hydra Collective; Axis Hating Sheeple; Allied Butt Buddy! Collect Them All!
Also the African Branch of TAB Bulletins
PS: The Italian Army fought with courage and skill
Also the African Branch of TAB Bulletins
PS: The Italian Army fought with courage and skill
23 Jun 2015, 10:00 AM
#46
Posts: 3552 | Subs: 2
This will need updating
However it will take a while for the meta to settle down before any real judgement can be made
However it will take a while for the meta to settle down before any real judgement can be made
Resident Soviet Whiner and Grand Master Bias Jedi; General Secretary of the Soviet Whine Hydra Collective; Axis Hating Sheeple; Allied Butt Buddy! Collect Them All!
Also the African Branch of TAB Bulletins
PS: The Italian Army fought with courage and skill
Also the African Branch of TAB Bulletins
PS: The Italian Army fought with courage and skill
23 Jun 2015, 15:17 PM
#47
Posts: 15
This will need updating
However it will take a while for the meta to settle down before any real judgement can be made
Nice thread.
A link for each Commander listed would be also nice. ☺
Heavy Tank Commander's got nerfed, so (Shock Rifle Frontline Tactics, Armored Assault Tactics
Assault Support Doctrine, Mechanized Assault Doctrine, Lightning War Doctrine, Spearhead Doctrine) 1 Tier worse imo. ☟
Again nice guide. 10/10. ☺
"Nothing is true, everything is permitted."
30 Jul 2015, 21:03 PM
#48
Posts: 446 | Subs: 2
pls update with preliminary placement of new balance or big old spoiler as to the outdatedness of the guide.
As for the preliminary placement, one can add little green pluses or red minuses next to commanders to indicate the general movement we can expect when the thing is updated. Probably off below with a clear indicator in order not to interfere with the current chart and confuse people even more
Edit: If not, it doesn't really matter. We can wait
As for the preliminary placement, one can add little green pluses or red minuses next to commanders to indicate the general movement we can expect when the thing is updated. Probably off below with a clear indicator in order not to interfere with the current chart and confuse people even more
Edit: If not, it doesn't really matter. We can wait
Dear Lord, teach me to be generous; to give and not count the cost; to fight and not heed the wounds; to work and ask for no reward, save that of knowing I am doing Your will.
Argumentation, disagreement, and debate are critical for success.
The most important type of diversity is viewpoint diversity.
Argumentation, disagreement, and debate are critical for success.
The most important type of diversity is viewpoint diversity.
30 Jul 2015, 21:26 PM
#49
14 
Posts: 10665 | Subs: 9
You will have to wait, Jaedrik.
Two of the authors are on leave and the third has his hands full with other forum business.
Two of the authors are on leave and the third has his hands full with other forum business.
31 Jul 2015, 00:46 AM
#50
Posts: 3552 | Subs: 2
Yeah, I am committed to keeping this up to date, but we had two patches in two months, I am away right now and then the Brits drop so I am not updating this until at least late September
Resident Soviet Whiner and Grand Master Bias Jedi; General Secretary of the Soviet Whine Hydra Collective; Axis Hating Sheeple; Allied Butt Buddy! Collect Them All!
Also the African Branch of TAB Bulletins
PS: The Italian Army fought with courage and skill
Also the African Branch of TAB Bulletins
PS: The Italian Army fought with courage and skill
3 Nov 2015, 03:03 AM
#51
Posts: 446 | Subs: 2
As always, I'd love for this to be updated in accord with the new meta and commanders, but I know there are complications, obscurities, and difficulties
Dear Lord, teach me to be generous; to give and not count the cost; to fight and not heed the wounds; to work and ask for no reward, save that of knowing I am doing Your will.
Argumentation, disagreement, and debate are critical for success.
The most important type of diversity is viewpoint diversity.
Argumentation, disagreement, and debate are critical for success.
The most important type of diversity is viewpoint diversity.
23 Nov 2015, 16:49 PM
#52
Posts: 208
I know there's another patch incoming, but nonetheless it would be great to see this updated. Especially if some pro players would decide to drop their 2 cents.
23 Nov 2015, 16:51 PM
#53
Posts: 3552 | Subs: 2
Yes, it's on our list to do
Resident Soviet Whiner and Grand Master Bias Jedi; General Secretary of the Soviet Whine Hydra Collective; Axis Hating Sheeple; Allied Butt Buddy! Collect Them All!
Also the African Branch of TAB Bulletins
PS: The Italian Army fought with courage and skill
Also the African Branch of TAB Bulletins
PS: The Italian Army fought with courage and skill
24 Nov 2015, 04:18 AM
#54
1 
Posts: 3052 | Subs: 15
This is a getting a massive update, as, we, speak.
24 Nov 2015, 07:50 AM
#55
Posts: 1063
I think Rifle Company should be Tier 1 and Airborne Tier 2. OKW Elite Armour is much more viable since Sturmtiger change and they are borderline OP against Brit who use emplacements.
26 Nov 2015, 00:47 AM
#56
1 
Posts: 2885
I think you guys should reconsider all pak43 commander placements. Every single pak43 ostheer commander is rated super low and it is not even mentioned that it has the ability while OKW fortifications are placed high with reasoning that the commander has said unit with mines, bunkers and mgs that ostheer also has cheaper or better.
I understand that the guide assesses commanders not army strength but it looks like okw with T1 commander was worth same as ostheer with T4 commander.
I understand that the guide assesses commanders not army strength but it looks like okw with T1 commander was worth same as ostheer with T4 commander.
26 Nov 2015, 01:11 AM
#57
1 Posts: 3052 | Subs: 15
I think you guys should reconsider all pak43 commander placements. Every single pak43 ostheer commander is rated super and it is not even mentioned that it has the ability while OKW fortifications are placed high with reasoning that the commander has said unit with mines, bunkers and mgs that ostheer also has cheaper or better.
I understand that the guide assesses commanders not army strength but it looks like okw with T1 commander was worth same as ostheer with T4 commander.
I'm sorry but where is there a super rated Pak43 ostheer commander? Not one of them is above tier 3, and the highest defensive rating for a pak43 ostheer doc is..... A "super" (average)3.
Fortifications has a 4 for defense(mainly because it gives OKW things for defense that they normally wouldn't have in S-mines, pak43, and MG) and is in tier 2, only slightly higher than joint ops.
26 Nov 2015, 01:26 AM
#58
1 Posts: 2885
I'm sorry but where is there a super rated Pak43 ostheer commander? Not one of them is above tier 3, and the highest defensive rating for a pak43 ostheer doc is..... A "super" (average)3.
Fortifications has a 4 for defense(mainly because it gives OKW things for defense that they normally wouldn't have in S-mines, pak43, and MG) and is in tier 2, only slightly higher than joint ops.
I ment "super low" sorry for the typo.
26 Nov 2015, 03:46 AM
#59
Posts: 446 | Subs: 2
YESSSS UPDATE HYPE
Typo in Elite Armored with the
smiley instead of 
kayguy:
typo in FAQ where the question / answer about updates is glommed into the answer about the romeo mug emote rating.
Typo in Elite Armored with the
smiley instead of kayguy:typo in FAQ where the question / answer about updates is glommed into the answer about the romeo mug emote rating.
Dear Lord, teach me to be generous; to give and not count the cost; to fight and not heed the wounds; to work and ask for no reward, save that of knowing I am doing Your will.
Argumentation, disagreement, and debate are critical for success.
The most important type of diversity is viewpoint diversity.
Argumentation, disagreement, and debate are critical for success.
The most important type of diversity is viewpoint diversity.
26 Nov 2015, 07:41 AM
#60
Posts: 138
I noticed jaeger infantry for wehrmacht wasn't mentioned (German infantry is a different doctrine).
26 Nov 2015, 08:16 AM
#61
Posts: 275 | Subs: 1
1)Armored Assault don't have Conscript repair kit.
2) "Ml20 howitzer brings a strong offense late game" sounds like trolling.
3) Anti Infantry have Reserv army icon.
4) "Strong defensive infantry...hit the dirt PPSH-Conscripts" sounds like trolling.
5) Combined Arms Army and Shock Army have same icon.
6) Tank Hunters don't have Mark Vehicle. No one word about salvage kit.
7) Tactical Support don't have Mortar Cover.
8) Elite Armour: ...Vehicle detection is a Decent ability that allows you to detect tanks... However: OKW has the IR Halftrack, so you can use that instead...
Wrong. Vehicle detection shows ALL MINIMAP, IR Halftrack shows only nearby himself.
2) "Ml20 howitzer brings a strong offense late game" sounds like trolling.
3) Anti Infantry have Reserv army icon.
4) "Strong defensive infantry...hit the dirt PPSH-Conscripts" sounds like trolling.
5) Combined Arms Army and Shock Army have same icon.
6) Tank Hunters don't have Mark Vehicle. No one word about salvage kit.
7) Tactical Support don't have Mortar Cover.
8) Elite Armour: ...Vehicle detection is a Decent ability that allows you to detect tanks... However: OKW has the IR Halftrack, so you can use that instead...
Wrong. Vehicle detection shows ALL MINIMAP, IR Halftrack shows only nearby himself.
Victory needs no explanation, defeat allows none
2 users are browsing this thread:
2 guests
